Case # | Name | Category | Court | Judge | Published |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
21-376
|
Haaland v. Brackeen
Indian Child Welfare Act's Indian family placement preferences did not violate Congress's Article I powers because Congress's power to legislate regarding Indian affairs was plenary even in state custody proceedings. |
Native American Affairs |
|
A. Barrett | Jun. 16, 2023 |
21-1576
|
Smith v. U.S.
The Constitution permits the retrial of a defendant following vacatur for a trial in an improper venue conducted before a jury drawn from the wrong district. |
Criminal Law and Procedure |
|
S. Alito | Jun. 16, 2023 |
22-55504
|
Leach v. Kijakazi
Administrative Law Judge's omission of an important qualifying adjective when questioning vocational expert about jobs available for a hypothetical person with disability claimant's mental limitations was not a harmless error. |
Administrative Agencies |
|
S. Graber | Jun. 16, 2023 |
22-15352
|
Aargon Agency Inc. v. O'Laughlin
Denial of temporary restraining order and preliminary injunction was appropriate where debt collectors failed to establish their facial challenge to Nevada S.B. 248 was likely to succeed on the merits. |
Consumer Law |
|
W. Fletcher | Jun. 16, 2023 |
B310777
|
Lucas v. City of Pomona
Overlay district established by city for its commercial cannabis permit program was exempt from California Environmental Quality Act because it was consistent with the existing general plan and environmental report. |
Environmental Law |
|
M. Stratton | Jun. 15, 2023 |
B319448
|
Modification: People v. Odell
Prosecutor's potentially ambiguous statements about a heat of passion defense were irrelevant because video evidence showed the allegedly provocating confrontation was relatively minor. |
Criminal Law and Procedure |
|
J. Wiley | Jun. 15, 2023 |
F084913
|
Modification: North American Title Company v. Superior Court (Cortina)
Insurance companies' judge disqualification claim, based on judge's bias because of comments regarding companies' chicanery, was unwaivable. |
Judges |
|
M. Smith | Jun. 15, 2023 |
21-35936
|
Wildearth Guardians v. U.S. Forest Service
Environmental groups lacked standing where they could not demonstrate possible lethal removal of wolves from Colville Forest was traceable to U.S. Forest Service, which neither regulated nor performed removals. |
Civil Procedure |
|
E. Miller | Jun. 15, 2023 |
22-50064
|
U.S. v. Lucas
Finding that defendant's firearm could accept a large capacity magazine, which subjected him to a sentence enhancement with an extremely disproportionate impact, was not supported by clear and convincing evidence. |
Criminal Law and Procedure |
|
J. Wallace | Jun. 15, 2023 |
People v. Waqa
Opinion |
|
Jun. 14, 2023 | |||
A163761
|
People v. Waqa
Evidence that was insufficient to support defendant's enhanced sentence for aggravated kidnapping was still sufficient to support an enhanced sentence for the lesser included offense of simple kidnapping. |
Criminal Law and Procedure |
|
J. Humes | Jun. 15, 2023 |
21-55859
|
U.S. Securities & Exchange Commission v. Husain
Summary judgment and imposition of $1,757,000 civil penalty were inappropriate where genuine issues of material fact existed as to the amount of the defendant's gross pecuniary gain and scienter. |
Securities |
|
K. Vratil | Jun. 14, 2023 |
21-56228
|
U.S. v. PetroSaudi Oil Services
Funds held in account controlled by High Court of England and Wales were not shielded by Foreign Sovereign Immunities Act because privately-owned corporate entity still retained ownership of the funds. |
Civil Procedure |
|
W. Fletcher | Jun. 14, 2023 |
22-30141
|
U.S. v. Alaniz
Sentencing enhancement for possessing a firearm during the commission of felony offense was constitutional because it was consistent with this Nation's historical tradition of regulating the right to bear arms. |
Criminal Law and Procedure |
|
P. Gutierrez | Jun. 14, 2023 |
22-15714
|
Grabowski v. Arizona Board of Regents
University athlete's Title IX harassment claim required allegations that specifically established a link between teammates' severely bullying behavior based on his perceived sexual orientation and resultant missed educational opportunities. |
Education |
|
S. Graber | Jun. 14, 2023 |
22-35474
|
Donovan v. Vance
Federal employees' and contractors' challenge to Executive Orders mandating COVID-19 vaccines was moot since recent Executive Order explicitly revoked the challenged Orders. |
Civil Procedure |
|
R. Clifton | Jun. 14, 2023 |
A165012
|
Claremont Canyon Conservancy v. Regents of the University of California
Environmental impact report for vegetation removal projects at the University of California, Berkeley was sufficiently specific since it allowed the public to understand the projects' environmental consequences. |
Environmental Law |
|
V. Rodriguez | Jun. 13, 2023 |
22-35216
|
Evans v. McCallister
Chapter 13 Trustee was not entitled to any fees from funds paid pursuant to a proposed bankruptcy plan when the Chapter 13 case was dismissed before the plan was confirmed. |
Bankruptcy |
|
M. Smith | Jun. 13, 2023 |
B319536
|
Coalition for Historical Integrity v. City of San Buenaventura
No CEQA violation where city found statue not historically significant, as a report plus finding that it was less than 40 years old rebutted presumption of its historical significance. |
Environmental Law |
|
A. Gilbert | Jun. 12, 2023 |
H049994
|
Mohler v. County of Santa Clara
County's allowance of local airport's disrepair did not fall within Code of Civil Procedure Section 526a's restrictive meaning of wasteful expenditure. |
Government |
|
D. Bromberg | Jun. 12, 2023 |
A164736
|
Raju v. Superior Court
Plaintiffs sufficiently alleged a taxpayer cause of action based upon the court's asserted violations of statutes that require expediting and prioritizing criminal proceedings. |
Civil Procedure |
|
J. Whitman | Jun. 12, 2023 |
A166150
|
Modification: In re S.F
Child was improperly removed from father's physical custody when presented evidence could not meet heightened standard required for removal. |
Dependency |
|
K. Banke | Jun. 12, 2023 |
20-99012
|
Ybarra v. Gittere
Defendant sentenced to die was not intellectually disabled because the IQ evidence portrayed him as someone with intelligence that was not significantly subaverage. |
Criminal Law and Procedure |
|
R. Tallman | Jun. 12, 2023 |
22-15080
|
McGinity v. The Procter & Gamble Co.
Reasonable consumer would not have been deceived by ambiguous front label on products where the back labels both clarified the front label's meaning and provided an ingredients list. |
Consumer Law |
|
R. Gould | Jun. 12, 2023 |
F084228
|
Tulare Lake Canal Co. v. Stratford Public Utility District
Failure to comply with California Environmental Quality Act requirements can create a lack of information which harms the public interest in informed decisionmaking and, consequently, can support granting a preliminary injunction. |
Environmental Law |
|
R. Peña | Jun. 9, 2023 |
21-1086
|
Allen v. Milligan
The districting plan adopted by the State of Alabama for its 2022 congressional elections likely violates Section 2 of the Voting Rights Act. |
Government |
|
J. Roberts | Jun. 9, 2023 |
22-10
|
Dubin v. U.S.
Fraudulent Medicaid claim did not automatically equate to "aggravated identity theft." |
Health Care |
|
S. Sotomayor | Jun. 9, 2023 |
22-148
|
Jack Daniel's Properties, Inc. v. VIP Products LLC
While dog toy company used Jack Daniel's trademarked bottle design and logo in a humorous way, their chew toy was not an "expressive work" that avoided analysis of consumer confusion. |
Intellectual Property |
|
E. Kagan | Jun. 9, 2023 |
E080436
|
Modification: Garcia v. Superior Court (Bianco)
Peremptory challenge to judge's assignment was properly denied as untimely because habeas proceeding was a continuation of the earlier criminal action. |
Criminal Law and Procedure |
|
Jun. 9, 2023 | |
21-806
|
Health and Hospital Corporation of Marion County v. Talevski
Provisions of the Federal Nursing Home Reform Act conferred individual rights that were enforceable via an action filed pursuant to 42 U.S.C. Section 1983. |
Civil Rights |
|
K. Jackson | Jun. 9, 2023 |