This is the property of the Daily Journal Corporation and fully protected by copyright. It is made available only to Daily Journal subscribers for personal or collaborative purposes and may not be distributed, reproduced, modified, stored or transferred without written permission. Please click "Reprint" to order presentation-ready copies to distribute to clients or use in commercial marketing materials or for permission to post on a website. and copyright (showing year of publication) at the bottom.


participatory / Appellate Practice

Evolving First and Second Amendments

audio

This week our guests address developments in First and Second Amendment jurisprudence that relate closely to recent California case law.

Paul Levy, from Public Citizen, contends that the First District Court of Appeal should have, in last week's ruling ZL Technologies v. Doe, endorsed a stricter standard applied to defamation plaintiffs seeking the identities of anonymous online posters on review sites. There, the 1DCA approved a test requiring plaintiffs make out a prima facie case of defamation, but didn't go as far as the prevailing majority rule, which involves a balancing of equities, and requires plaintiffs to show why such a balancing favors them.

David Kopel then will address the consolidated cases of Wrenn v. District of Columbia and Matthew Grace and Pink Pistols v. District of Columbia, which were decided by a split D.C. Circuit court this week, and in which the panel struck down a regulation requiring D.C. gun owners to show they had a special need to carry their firearms in public. The ruling conflicts, at least arguably, with the 9th Circuit's Peruta decision, which affirming the propriety of California's 'good cause' requirement gun owners must meet to be allow to get a concealed carry permit. The disharmony in the opinions could potentially compel the U.S. Supreme Court to address the matter in the near future.

#121


Related Tests for Appellate practice

general/Appellate Practice

Poco loco rules

By Benjamin G. Shatz

general/Appellate Practice

Delay in our Courts of Appeal

By Kirk C. Jenkins

general/Appellate Practice

Appeals in traffic infraction cases

By Gail Dekreon

participatory/Appellate Practice

Open Carry and the 'Core' of the Second Amendment


general/Appellate Practice

Avoid common mistakes to give your writ petition a better chance

By Sharon Baumgold

general/Appellate Practice

A riddle (almost) as old as California

By Brian M. Hoffstadt

participatory/Appellate Practice

Considering Kavanaugh