Law Office Management
Oct. 2, 2014
Interior Views
An architecture writer takes a look at innovative office design at three law firms in Southern California.
Most firms don't have the opportunity to design a building from scratch. When Paul Hastings wanted to modernize its Orange County office, the firm decided to work within the existing building in Costa Mesa - several floors in an 18-story high rise. The office, with practices including corporate, litigation, real estate, tax, and employment law, sought to repurpose its 18th-floor space that held the library, and to consolidate all 36 attorneys and staff onto the 17th floor, returning the 16th floor to the building when the lease was up for renegotiation. (Another floor, with conference rooms, was updated in 2010.) To accomplish this, Paul Hastings enlisted its longtime interior architecture firm, Rottet Studio. The studio's design credits include many law offices in the country - including Seyfarth Shaw's Houston office and Morrison & Foerster in San Francisco - and it's currently working on Foley & Lardner's office in New York City. Rottet has designed numerous Paul Hastings offices overseas, including in Seoul, Tokyo, Milan, Shanghai, London, and Paris. Laurence Cartledge, whose team masterminded some of those designs, took on the Costa Mesa overhaul. The first step, as Los Angeles-based Cartledge saw it, was to eliminate much of the library, which took up most of the 18th floor, and use the space instead for a staff break room, a videoconference room, staff support, a smaller library, and a high-density file room. "Libraries are becoming things of the past in law firms," he says. "A lot of what we're seeing is libraries shrinking. ... The space that's growing is the open area, collaborative space." To eliminate a floor and yet make room for the new collaborative areas that the firm wanted, strategic choices had to be made: Office sizes would have to be reduced. Junior attorneys saw a decrease from 150 square feet to 100 square feet, associate spaces went from 145 square feet to 125, and some senior partner offices were scaled back from 250 square feet to just under 200. The new sizes didn't faze the attorneys. What did make them skittish was the accompanying plan: replacing solid office walls along the hall with glass. "The lack of visual privacy will be the biggest jump and usually the hardest pill to swallow for all the attorneys," says Cartledge. The transparency has multiple benefits: It allows daylight to reach deeper into the office, and it promotes connectedness, which increases morale. "Typically in the past, the partners were behind closed doors and closed walls," says Cartledge. "And a lot of times there's a mystery as to what's going on back there. By introducing glass, we were able to create more of a connection, which seems to be driven by the desire of the younger attorneys to feel more a part of what's going on." John F. Simonis, chair of Paul Hastings's Orange County office in Costa Mesa, describes the changes as "tearing down barriers," both physical and psychological, and says he has witnessed a new tone in the office. "The most surprising thing is that people actually like the glass-walled offices," says Simonis. "You can close your door and have sound privacy anyway. The light and energy that it brings to the office more than offset the change in privacy." Transparency can also have its disadvantages. Though the state of California requires employers to provide a lactation room, many lawyers with newborns prefer to keep working in their offices while rigged up to the breast pumps. After one attorney from the OC office gave birth and another was expecting soon, "it stirred up a lot of discussion," says Cartledge. He offered several solutions involving screens before the firm finally decided on curtains that could stretch across the glass wall. When an attorney no longer needs the privacy, the drapery and track can be removed and reinstalled as needed. "Everyone seems to be happy with a solution that addresses a temporary issue." To foster connection among employees, Rottet designed the 17th floor with only one break room and beverage center. "People enjoy congregating at the counter, talking about local happenings, or specifics of work," Cartledge notes. On the 18th floor, deft handling of floor space made room for an attractive new lounge area (photo above), which features a wall of diner booths, each with a flat computer screen on the wall in place of a jukebox. Stretching the length of the area is a beige sofa, accessorized with orange, white, and gray throw pillows. Cropped rectangles of wavy wallpaper here and there add visual interest. "We're designing for the future, for people coming out of law school now," Simonis says of the space, "but everyone's adapted to it." "A lot of younger people were really attracted to joining a firm that had a progressive face," Cartledge says of the redesign. However, he acknowledges that similar changes may not work everywhere. "If you're in Atlanta and they're able to offer all first-years 150 square feet of office, it becomes more difficult for them to adopt a different way of thinking and reduce the size of a first-year office to 100 square feet." Even so, he anticipates that someday summer associates and first-year associates will be moving to interior offices or doubling up in a window office. "It might be a big deal to people who are 50 or 60," he says, though younger lawyers, accustomed to multitasking in coffee shops or squeezing into small apartments in big cities, aren't as likely to mind. Transparency, collaborative areas, and smaller offices are all part of the "office of the future" initiative that Rottet put together for Paul Hastings, some of which is based on research conducted by large furniture manufacturers about work habits of the younger generation. While the nature of law necessitates quiet spaces to focus, Cartledge says, today's graduates are "used to noise surrounding them." The strategies have been so effective in the Costa Mesa office that they're being deployed in a total gut-and-redesign in Chicago, where office footprints will be reduced to as little as 81 square feet (9 by 9). Additional mandates include better computer and telecommunications technology, and standardized office furniture for senior partners, much of it made by the modern furniture company Knoll. "Change is hard," says Cartledge. "It takes a few people to take that jump and leap of faith and spend the money and do it and see how it works before others are willing to follow suit."
Photo credit: Marjorie Salvaterra
Dordi Williams Cohen, a three-attorney civil litigation and criminal defense firm that opened its doors in January, knew it wanted to be in downtown Los Angeles, though its office design was up for grabs. After many months of searching for space at the right size and price, the partners selected a location in a restored 1915 building, says managing partner and civil litigator Marc S. Williams. "I think we're the only lawyers in the building." Other tenants are architects, tech companies, and fashion businesses. "We were attracted to the vibe." His fellow partners, Reuven L. Cohen and Firdaus F. Dordi, are former federal public defenders. "We didn't want to be in a traditional space, surrounded at all times by other lawyers," says Williams. "We thought it would be better for us to be around creative people while we do our law. Being a lawyer is not a relaxed profession, but our environment is relaxed." Ideas for the interiors evolved over months. "We wanted our space to have an open feeling, but at the same time, we needed privacy and quiet. Our landlord worked with us to build out separate offices using lots of glass. Our space is sleek, minimalist, and filled with light." Covering a little more than 2,500 square feet, it features four internal offices, a conference room, and what the partners call the "bourbon room" - an informal space with an exposed brick wall that's used for collaboration and cocktails. Double-hung windows allow for fresh air. The polished concrete floors shimmer. "We love our space," says Williams, noting that the minimalist look complements the downtown dynamic. "It fills us with the energy we need to tackle the serious and complex legal issues that we handle every day." Business seems brisk. "We're thinking of turning our conference room into two more offices so we can grow, and turning the bourbon room into the conference room." A former editor at Architectural Digest, Mary Ore has written for various publications, including The New York Times and The Sunday Times.
Kari Santos
For reprint rights or to order a copy of your photo:
Email
jeremy@reprintpros.com
for prices.
Direct dial: 949-702-5390
Send a letter to the editor:
Email: letters@dailyjournal.com