This is the property of the Daily Journal Corporation and fully protected by copyright. It is made available only to Daily Journal subscribers for personal or collaborative purposes and may not be distributed, reproduced, modified, stored or transferred without written permission. Please click "Reprint" to order presentation-ready copies to distribute to clients or use in commercial marketing materials or for permission to post on a website. and copyright (showing year of publication) at the bottom.

Labor/Employment

Oct. 16, 2026

Feeling the heat: Investigations of menopause-related accommodation complaints

Menopause-related accommodation complaints do not require a new investigative approach, but they can present sensitive factual questions. Investigators must evaluate the evidence without allowing assumptions or stereotypes to influence their findings.

Christina Ro-Connolly

Founding Partner
Oppenheimer Investigations Group LLP

See more...

Lauren Numeroff

Attorney
Oppenheimer Investigations Group LLP

See more...

Feeling the heat: Investigations of menopause-related accommodation complaints
Shutterstock

Menopause-related accommodation complaints do not call for a new investigative method. But they can present unusually personal facts within a familiar workplace framework. An employee may need to explain private, variable symptoms that others cannot see. A manager may be trying to understand what the employee needs while addressing attendance, performance, staffing or other workplace concerns. By the time a failure to accommodate complaint reaches an investigator, those experiences may have hardened into competing accounts of what went wrong.

Often, an employer's internal investigators or decision-makers are tasked with determining whether a complainant's allegation of a failure to accommodate has merit. In those situations, the employer's agents must evaluate what the employee communicated, what the employer/respondent understood, how the parties navigated the accommodation process, and whether the evidence supports the reasons later offered for the decisions at issue.

The law is beginning to address the issue expressly with respect to menopause-related accommodations. Rhode Island amended its fair-employment law in 2025 to require reasonable accommodation of menopause and related medical conditions. The federal Menopausal Workers' Fairness Act of 2026, introduced in July, would create an accommodation framework for known menopause-related limitations without requiring each limitation to satisfy the Americans with Disabilities Act's definition of disability. California's AB 1940 would have added perimenopause, menopause, postmenopause and related medical conditions to the Fair Employment and Housing Act's definition of sex. The governor vetoed the bill on Sept. 30, 2026.

These developments make menopause-related accommodations more visible, but the disputes are not new. Depending on the facts, policy and jurisdiction, a complaint may implicate accommodation, discrimination, retaliation or overlapping theories. The investigator's role is not to assume that a request was mishandled or decide legal questions beyond the assigned scope. It is to develop a fair record of the communications, conduct and decisions at issue, particularly when it comes to allegations of a failure to accommodate.

Reconstructing the process

The first task when investigating an allegation of a failure to accommodate is to reconstruct what happened before the parties understood the matter as a dispute. What did the employee communicate, to whom and when? What workplace limitation did the employee identify? What information did the employer/respondent request? What alternatives did the parties discuss? Was the request to accommodate approved, modified, delayed or denied? Did anyone revisit the arrangement when circumstances changed?

The record may reveal a discrete breakdown rather than a wholesale failure. A delay may have followed an unresolved request for information. An approved accommodation may not have addressed the limitation described. A proposal may have been rejected without considering alternatives. The record may instead show sustained efforts to obtain necessary information and identify a workable option.

Documentation matters, but volume does not establish a sound process. For instance, a file filled with forms and emails may never explain why an accommodation request was rejected. At the same time, a shorter record may show that the parties identified the limitation, considered alternatives and reached a reasoned decision. The question is whether the evidence reflects an individualized process and a reasoned response, or whether the outcome preceded the inquiry.

Defining the medical inquiry

Failure to accommodate complaints may expose uncertainty about the appropriate scope of medical documentation. An employer may need enough information to understand the functional limitation, its expected duration and the basis for the requested accommodation. That need does not ordinarily extend to the employee's complete medical history or every detail of diagnosis and treatment.

The line becomes harder to draw when symptoms are varied, personal or unfamiliar to the decision-maker. For the employee, explaining the limitation may require disclosing information she would ordinarily keep private. For the employer, an accommodation decision may require enough information to act without inviting an inquiry broader than necessary. However, a lack of familiarity with a condition such as menopause may prompt requests for excessive personal information. It may also lead a decision-maker to dismiss a limitation that falls outside a common understanding of menopause.

With respect to employer document requests, the investigation should examine both the stated reason for the request and its scope. Was the information sought relevant to the accommodation decision? Was comparable documentation required in similar circumstances? Who received the information, how was it maintained and was it used for another purpose? California regulations, for example, require medical or psychological information obtained through the accommodation process to be maintained separately and treated as confidential, subject to limited exceptions.

Assessing workplace impact

The harder evidentiary question is often not whether the employee experienced symptoms, but how those symptoms affected working conditions. Common menopausal symptoms, such as hot flashes, sleep disruption, fatigue, pain, anxiety, memory concerns and difficulty concentrating, may be intermittent, subjective or invisible to coworkers. The employee's account should be considered with the rest of the record.

Also, relevant evidence may include contemporaneous communications, changes in schedule or performance, medical support, the relationship between the reported limitation and requested accommodation, and changes over time. Witnesses may describe what they observed, but they should not diagnose the employee or speculate about medical cause.

Moreover, careful evaluation does not mean automatic acceptance. Investigators and decision-makers may consider severity, duration, workplace effect and plausible alternative explanations. In addition, preexisting performance concerns, operational changes, and/or interpersonal conflict may complicate the account. The investigator should not attempt to resolve medical questions that are unnecessary to the allegations. But where the existence, extent or workplace effect of a claimed limitation bears on a disputed accommodation decision, those facts cannot simply be assumed or disregarded. They should be evaluated through the same evidence-based process applied to disputed facts in any other type of investigation, while respecting the limits of the investigator's role and expertise. The object is not to decide what accommodation the investigator would have provided; it is to determine whether the factual premises on which the employer acted are supported by the evidence.

Separating context from conclusion

In addition to allegations of a failure to accommodate, some complaints will allege harassment, that is, disability-, age- or sex-based assumptions affected the employer's response. Comments about forgetfulness, emotionality, stamina, adaptability or suitability for leadership may be relevant because they relate to stereotypes associated with people experiencing menopause. However, the weight of this type of evidence depends on context: who made the comment, when it was made, whether the speaker influenced the decision, and whether the remark related to the reason later offered for the challenged action.

The same considerations apply to retaliation complaints. Increased scrutiny, reassigned duties, exclusion, discipline or an adverse review after an accommodation request may warrant investigation. A close proximity in time between the accommodation request and the adverse action may also establish a connection between the two events. Relevant questions include when concerns first arose, who knew about the request, whether expectations changed, and how comparable concerns were handled when no accommodation request was involved.

In sum, menopause-related investigations require neither special solicitude nor unique skepticism. As with all investigations, the evidence concerns people and processes. An employee may believe that a personal health issue changed how she was viewed at work; the employer may believe its decisions rested on unrelated, legitimate concerns. Each account should be considered and weighed against the evidence. With menopause-related complaints in particular, sympathy, discomfort regarding the topic, or assumptions based on stereotypes should not determine how the evidence is weighed.

#395340


Submit your own column for publication to Diana Bosetti


For reprint rights or to order a copy of your photo:

Email Jeremy_Ellis@dailyjournal.com for prices.
Direct dial: 213-229-5424

Send a letter to the editor:

Email: letters@dailyjournal.com



✓ California Assembly Bill 2323 Compliance Notice: Daily Journal Corporation newspapers meet all publication requirements established under California Assembly Bill 2323. Learn More