Litigation & Arbitration
Nov. 17, 2026
Justice blasts arbitration ruling as attack on freedom of contract
In a sharply worded dissent, Justice John Shepard Wiley Jr. accused his colleagues of applying arbitration-specific standards that conflict with federal law and threaten to invite another U.S. Supreme Court reversal.
A Court of Appeal justice accused his colleagues of using a "20-pound sledgehammer" to invalidate an employment arbitration agreement, warning that the decision perpetuates a longstanding conflict between California courts and the U.S. Supreme Court over the enforceability of arbitration contracts.
In a sharply worded dissent Friday, Justice John Shepard Wiley Jr. argued that California courts have developed special rules for declaring arbitration agreements unconscionable that do not apply to other contracts, violating the Federal Arbitration Act.
"There is no equal treatment in this case," Wiley wrote. "The majority takes apart this arbitration contract using a 20-pound sledgehammer found nowhere else in general contract law."
The 2-1 ruling by the 2nd District Court of Appeal affirmed a Los Angeles County judge's refusal to compel arbitration of employment claims brought by Tracie Bennett against VXI Global Solutions LLC, a company that operates customer service call centers.
Justice Victor Viramontes, joined by Presiding Justice Maria E. Stratton, concluded that the agreement was unconscionable because it covered claims unrelated to Bennett's employment, continued indefinitely and imposed obligations that disproportionately favored the employer and third-party beneficiaries.
Wiley disputed the majority's reasoning, particularly its conclusion that the agreement was unfair because it extended beyond employment-related disputes.
"The trial court ruled the scope of the contract was unfair because it covered non-employment as well as employment claims," Wiley wrote. "This, however, was not overly harsh or so one-sided that it shocks the conscience. It was not even close."
He rejected Bennett's argument that the agreement was excessively broad.
"General contract law, however, has never contained a doctrine of 'overbreadth,'" Wiley wrote. "The contrary is true. The familiar principle of contract law is to allow parties to determine the scope of their relationship."
Wiley argued that broad contractual provisions are commonplace, including in settlement agreements, and that courts should not impose special limitations simply because a contract requires arbitration.
He also challenged the majority's objections to the agreement's indefinite duration and its refusal to sever provisions deemed unlawful.
The majority rejected Wiley's federal preemption argument, maintaining that its unconscionability analysis applied generally accepted contract principles rather than rules targeting arbitration.
Wiley warned that the decision risked another rebuke from the U.S. Supreme Court, which has repeatedly overturned California arbitration rulings.
"California state arbitration law and the supreme federal preemption power have been butting heads for years," he wrote. "In these collisions, California state law always loses."
Laura Reathaford and Jeffrey Richmond of Lathrop GPM represent VXI Global Solutions LLC. Joseph Lavi, Jordan D. Bello and Brett Szmanda of Lavi & Ebrahimian represented the plaintiff, Tracie Bennett. Neither could be reached for comment.
The case is Bennett v. VXI Global Solutions, LLC, B346763 (2nd Dist., Div. 8, filed Nov. 13, 2026).
For reprint rights or to order a copy of your photo:
Email
Jeremy_Ellis@dailyjournal.com
for prices.
Direct dial: 213-229-5424
Send a letter to the editor:
Email: letters@dailyjournal.com