This is the property of the Daily Journal Corporation and fully protected by copyright. It is made available only to Daily Journal subscribers for personal or collaborative purposes and may not be distributed, reproduced, modified, stored or transferred without written permission. Please click "Reprint" to order presentation-ready copies to distribute to clients or use in commercial marketing materials or for permission to post on a website. and copyright (showing year of publication) at the bottom.
News

Torts/Personal Injury

Nov. 17, 2026

Appeals court overturns $27M verdict against San Bernardino County in deputy abuse case

Justices found insufficient evidence that reporting suspected child neglect would have prevented a sheriff's employee from sexually abusing a boy. The plaintiff's attorney plans to seek California Supreme Court review.

A Court of Appeal on Monday overturned a $27 million judgment against San Bernardino County, ruling that a man sexually abused by a sheriff's department employee failed to prove that county workers' failure to report suspected child neglect caused his injuries.

The 4th District Court of Appeal, Division 2, concluded that expert testimony did not establish that a child protective services investigation would have prevented Jeremie Cox, a sheriff's department bailiff, from sexually abusing the plaintiff, identified as John Doe.

Christopher Keane of Keane Law, one of Doe's attorneys, sharply criticized the ruling and said the plaintiff intends to request publication of the appellate opinion and petition the California Supreme Court for review.

"They were incorrect factually and incorrect legally," Keane said.

Keane also criticized the appellate court's handling of the case, saying its tentative ruling relied on matters that neither party had addressed in its briefs.

"It wasn't even briefed by us," he said.

Keane said the plaintiffs requested an opportunity to submit supplemental briefing, but the court denied the request.

He compared the decision to the 4th District's handling of B.H. v. County of San Bernardino, a 2015 case in which, he said, the California Supreme Court unanimously reversed the appellate court.

"They think they know child abuse and neglect reporting and causation better than the experts, or even the neglected, runaway plaintiff himself, who was sexually abused more than 1000 times, but they don't.  The jury understood it, and so did the trial judge," Keane said. 

Nadia A. Sarkis of Miller Barondess, who represented the county, said the plaintiffs' case failed because it relied on speculation rather than evidence establishing causation.

"The central flaw in Plaintiffs' case was overreach and ignoring the fundamentals of a plaintiff's obligation to meet his burden of proof," Sarkis said. "Expert testimony was necessary to prove causation and Plaintiffs' own expert admitted that Plaintiffs' abuser would not have been deterred, even if County employees had reported another party--Plaintiff's mother--for purported neglect."

Justice Marsha G. Fields, writing for the unanimous panel, said the plaintiff's theory depended on speculation about how social workers would have responded to a neglect report, whether they would have discovered the abuse and what protective measures they might have implemented.

Although experts testified that an investigation likely would have resulted in Doe's removal from Cox's home, they failed to establish what a subsequent safety plan would have required or how it would have prevented further abuse, Fields wrote.

The court noted that Doe's relationship with Cox began before he moved into the employee's home and included unsupervised visits. Evidence also established that abuse occurred outside the residence.

"Where a jury is left to merely speculate on possibilities, there is insufficient evidence to support a finding that the County's omissions were a cause in fact of plaintiff's harm," Fields wrote.

Cox pleaded no contest to at least 10 sexual offenses involving Doe.

The jury awarded Doe $33 million in damages, with the resulting judgment against the county exceeding $27 million.

In a separate concurrence, Justice Frank J. Menetrez offered another reason to reject liability, concluding that Doe's mother had not neglected him merely by arranging for other adults to provide his care.

Sarkis said the county recognizes its responsibilities to report suspected child abuse and neglect but maintained that the lawsuit sought to expand those obligations beyond what the law requires.

"The County takes its obligations under the Child Abuse Neglect and Reporting Act seriously," she said. "But we are pleased that we were able to achieve a defense verdict based on untenable theories that distort public entities' duties under the law."

The panel directed San Bernardino County Superior Court Judge Jeffrey Erickson to enter judgment for the county.

The county was represented by Collins & Collins and Miller Barondess. Doe was represented by Keane Law and Esner, Chang, Boyer & Murphy.

The case is Doe v. County of San Bernardino, E085516 (4th Dist., Div. 2, Nov. 16, 2026). The opinion is unpublished.

#396225

David Houston

For reprint rights or to order a copy of your photo:

Email Jeremy_Ellis@dailyjournal.com for prices.
Direct dial: 213-229-5424

Send a letter to the editor:

Email: letters@dailyjournal.com