Nov. 18, 2026
California's complex court judges confront resource shortages, crowded dockets and demands for greater efficiency
At annual L.A. County Bar Association symposium, judges discuss civil case delays, coordinated litigation, trial management, AI-generated materials and attorneys' courtroom habits
California judges overseeing some of the state's most complicated civil litigation offered a candid assessment Wednesday of crowded dockets, limited resources and the courtroom habits that make difficult cases even harder to manage.
At the Los Angeles County Bar Association's annual Complex Courts Symposium, judges discussed everything from coordinated silicosis litigation and artificial intelligence to trial preparation and the importance of respecting jurors' time.
Santa Clara County Superior Court Judge Beth A. R. McGowen described the strain on civil courts as judicial resources are diverted to meet criminal trial obligations.
"If you were in my department today and a lawsuit was filed by you, say in July, you will have not been to the courtroom yet," McGowen said. "You will have not had a case management conference yet, and that motion to compel arbitration will not be set to be heard for another 10 months."
"I don't find that acceptable," she added. "That's not good for your case. That's not good for our court."
McGowen said courts have limited influence over funding decisions and pointed out that California's judiciary accounts for approximately 1% of the state budget.
The pressures are especially apparent in coordinated litigation, where judges must balance the interests of numerous plaintiffs and defendants while keeping cases moving toward trial.
Los Angeles County Superior Court Judge Elihu M. Berle described procedures used to manage approximately 700 coordinated silicosis cases pending in his court, including rules governing trial preferences and depositions involving multiple defendants.
When the same witnesses and factual issues arise across numerous lawsuits, Berle said, courts must find ways to avoid unnecessarily repeating testimony while protecting the parties' rights.
"We don't have to have Groundhog Day 20, 30 times," he said.
Berle also offered some straightforward advice to attorneys appearing in his courtroom.
"And finally, no jibber-jabber," he said. "When the attorneys presenting an argument, get right to the point. We don't want to go around in circles."
Berle praised the attorneys regularly handling silica litigation, describing experienced practitioners on both sides who generally maintain high professional standards. His criticism was directed more broadly at attorneys who occasionally appear in his courtroom.
Among his concerns were poorly prepared filings, including documents generated using artificial intelligence without adequate attorney review.
"We don't need any AI-written documents," Berle said. "It's embarrassing for the lawyers and embarrassing for the court to receive AI documents."
Other judges on the asbestos, talc and silica panel focused on trial readiness, unnecessarily lengthy summary judgment motions and attorneys who fail to promptly notify courts when cases settle.
Attorneys who announce they are ready for trial should be prepared to proceed, the judges said, rather than requesting additional weeks to organize their cases after receiving a trial assignment.
The panel included Berle, Los Angeles County Superior Court Judge Bruce G. Iwasaki, Alameda County Superior Court Judge Patrick R. McKinney II, Ventura County Superior Court Judge Charmaine H. Buehner and San Francisco County Superior Court Judge Rochelle C. East.
Buehner also cautioned attorneys about using artificial intelligence recording devices in court without obtaining judicial permission.
She described encountering briefs that appeared to quote her statements from earlier proceedings, despite no request for permission to record.
"And from my view, quoting the judge back to the judge is not a personal use of those notes," she said.
A separate panel, "Managing Complex Trials," examined how judges can streamline litigation through early case management, focused pretrial rulings and better preparation.
San Francisco County Superior Court Judge Jeffrey S. Ross encouraged attorneys to identify significant legal questions early, noting that resolving uncertainty can sometimes facilitate settlement.
Los Angeles County Superior Court Judge Theresa M. Traber described the challenges of managing Johnson & Johnson ovarian cancer litigation, including scientific disputes over causation and extensive pretrial motions.
Los Angeles County Superior Court Judge Elaine Lu said she generally does not impose numerical limits on motions in limine, recalling one case involving 74 such motions. But she criticized generic motions that fail to identify specific evidentiary disputes.
Lu also urged attorneys to prepare deposition designations well before trial, rather than leaving jurors waiting while lawyers resolve objections or edit video testimony.
San Francisco County Superior Court Judge Ethan P. Schulman recalled serving as a juror after becoming a judge and being left waiting outside a courtroom for 45 minutes without an explanation or apology.
The experience reinforced his view that attorneys and judges must respect jurors' time and minimize unnecessary interruptions.
Los Angeles County Superior Court Judge Carolyn B. Kuhl said attorneys sometimes become less organized in bench trials because they do not have a jury watching their presentation. She urged lawyers to approach trials before judges with the same preparation and discipline required in jury trials.
Across the panels, the message was consistent: Courts facing growing caseloads and limited resources need attorneys to arrive prepared, narrow their disputes and avoid wasting time.
Or, as Berle put it, dispense with the "jibber-jabber."
Correction: An earlier version of this article incorrectly attributed comments about civil court delays and judicial resources to Santa Clara County Superior Court Judge Elizabeth C. Peterson. The comments were made by Santa Clara County Superior Court Judge Beth A. R. McGowen. Peterson did not attend the symposium.
Diana Bosetti
diana_bosetti@dailyjournal.com
For reprint rights or to order a copy of your photo:
Email
Jeremy_Ellis@dailyjournal.com
for prices.
Direct dial: 213-229-5424
Send a letter to the editor:
Email: letters@dailyjournal.com