This is the property of the Daily Journal Corporation and fully protected by copyright. It is made available only to Daily Journal subscribers for personal or collaborative purposes and may not be distributed, reproduced, modified, stored or transferred without written permission. Please click "Reprint" to order presentation-ready copies to distribute to clients or use in commercial marketing materials or for permission to post on a website. and copyright (showing year of publication) at the bottom.

Constitutional Law

Nov. 23, 2026

Stop allowing discrimination based on religious beliefs

The Supreme Court's consideration of religious exemptions to Colorado's preschool anti-discrimination requirements raises broader questions about whether religious freedom should take precedence over laws protecting individuals from discrimination.

Erwin Chemerinsky

Dean and Jesse H. Choper Distinguished Professor of Law
UC Berkeley School of Law

Erwin's most recent book is "Worse Than Nothing: The Dangerous Fallacy of Originalism." He is also the author of "Closing the Courthouse," (Yale University Press 2017).

See more...

Stop allowing discrimination based on religious beliefs
Shutterstock

Should religious beliefs provide an exemption from anti-discrimination laws? The answer should be a resounding no. The government's interest in stopping discrimination--whether based on race, sex, religion, sexual orientation or gender identity--is a compelling interest. Unfortunately, though, the Supreme Court, in a case heard on Nov. 3, St. Mary Catholic Parish v. Roy, again seems poised to find that protecting free exercise of religion is more important than stopping discrimination.

There is always tension between liberty and equality. Every law that prohibits discrimination limits the freedom to discriminate. For decades, the Supreme Court consistently held that ending discrimination was more important than protecting those who asserted the freedom to discriminate. Employers who wanted to discriminate lost in their claims of a freedom to choose their employees, as did businesses that asserted a right to choose their customers. For example, in Newman v. Piggy Park Enterprises, Inc. (1968), the Court easily rejected a claim by a restaurant that the religious beliefs of its owners gave them a right to discriminate based on race in violation of the law.

For many reasons, this is right. In 1990, in Employment Division v. Smith, the Court held that free exercise of religion does not provide a basis for an exemption from general laws. The case involved Native Americans in Oregon who wanted a religious exception from the state law prohibiting consumption of peyote, a hallucinogenic substance. In an opinion by Justice Antonin Scalia, the Court ruled against the Native Americans and stressed that the Oregon law was not motivated by a desire to interfere with religion and applied to everyone in the state.

Additionally, free exercise of religion should not provide a basis for harming others. The famous adage--my right to swing my fist ends at another person's nose --is apt here. In light of the history of discrimination, the government should be seen as having an overriding interest even when people claim a right to discriminate based on their religious beliefs.

Unfortunately, in recent years, the Supreme Court has consistently gone in the other direction. In Masterpiece Cake Shop, Ltd. v. Colorado Civil Rights Commission (2018), the Court, albeit on narrow grounds, ruled in favor of a baker who refused to bake and design a cake for a gay couple. In Our Lady of Guadalupe School v. Morrissey-Beru (2020), the Court held that religious schools could not be held liable for discriminating based on age and disability in firing teachers of secular subjects. In Fulton v. City of Philadelphia (2021), the Court concluded that it violated free exercise of religion for Philadelphia to insist that social service agencies that contracted with the city to place children in foster care refrain from discriminating based on sexual orientation. And most recently, in 303 Creative v. Elenis (2023), the Court said that a web designer had a First Amendment free speech right to violate Colorado anti-discrimination law and to refuse to design websites for weddings for same-sex couples.

In these cases, the Court rejected decades of precedents and for the first time found that protecting the right to discriminate was more important than the government's interest in its laws prohibiting discrimination. That issue is again before the Supreme Court in St. Mary Catholic Parish v. Roy.

Colorado, in 2023, adopted a law providing for universal preschool for all children in the state. Under the program, the government will pay for preschool education at all public, secular private and faith-based preschools. The only condition is that they must sign an agreement that they will not discriminate against children based on their parents' race, ethnicity, religion, sexual orientation, gender identity, disability, income or lack of housing.

St. Mary Catholic Parish, in Littleton, Colorado, and other Catholic preschools in the Archdiocese of Denver refused to sign the agreement, saying that it conflicts with church teachings on marriage, sex and gender. Their objection is to having to agree to take children whose parents are gay, lesbian or transgender.

The lower federal courts upheld the Colorado law. They explained that under Employment Division v. Smith, the Colorado law did not violate free exercise of religion because it was not motivated by a desire to interfere with religion and it applied equally to everyone. The courts stressed that Colorado was not excluding religious schools from its program; the same requirements were imposed on all recipients of state money.

Unstated by the lower courts was the government's compelling interest in stopping discrimination against children because of the sexual orientation or gender identity of their parents. To be sure, the Catholic Church condemns same-sex sexual activity and gender transitions. But that should not give it the right to violate the state's anti-discrimination law and harm children by denying them preschool education.

Based on the oral arguments, it appears that once more the Court will say that religious beliefs require that the government provide an exception from its anti-discrimination laws. The conservative justices on the Court expressed support for the position that the Colorado law impermissibly burdened the plaintiffs' religion.

I do not see a stopping point if the Court continues down this path. Such a ruling will open the door to employers and businesses claiming a religious basis for discriminating based on race, sex or religion. An employer might claim, for example, that its religion mandates that men and women not work together and so it can hire only men.

The answer to all of this is for the Court to say again, as it used to, that the government has a compelling interest in stopping discrimination and there is no basis for granting religious exemptions from anti-discrimination laws. Period.

#396438


Submit your own column for publication to Diana Bosetti


For reprint rights or to order a copy of your photo:

Email Jeremy_Ellis@dailyjournal.com for prices.
Direct dial: 213-229-5424

Send a letter to the editor:

Email: letters@dailyjournal.com



✓ California Assembly Bill 2323 Compliance Notice: Daily Journal Corporation newspapers meet all publication requirements established under California Assembly Bill 2323. Learn More