 
Associate Justice
California Courts of Appeal
1st Appellate District, Division 2
Department/Division:
2
350 McAllister St.
San Francisco , CA 94102-3600
(415) 865-7300
Appointed to 1st District Court of Appeal, Division Two by Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger, 2006; appointed to the Alameda County Superior Court by Gov. Pete Wilson, 1996; partner, Cooley LLP, 1967-1996; assistant professor, Gonzaga University School of Law, 1966-1967; clerk, 1st District Court of Appeal Justice Raymond L. Sullivan, 1965-1966.
University of San Francisco School of Law, 1965
Judicial Profiles
| Title | Court | Published | 
|---|---|---|
| The Heavy | 1st Appellate District, Division 2 (San Francisco) | May 13, 2021 | 
| From Pen-and-Paper Man to Internet Guru | 1st District Court of Appeal | Oct. 23, 2007 | 
Rulings
| Case | Category | Published | 
|---|---|---|
| Birdsall v. Helfet author | Contracts | Aug. 12, 2025 | 
| Oakland Bulk and Oversized Terminal v. City of Oakland author | Contracts | Jun. 30, 2025 | 
| People v. Lewis author | Criminal Law and Procedure | Jun. 13, 2025 | 
| Medtronic USA v. California Dept. of Tax & Fee Admin. author | Tax | Apr. 17, 2025 | 
| People v. Hill author | Criminal Law and Procedure | Mar. 3, 2025 | 
| Watts v. Pneumo Abex author | Torts | Oct. 30, 2024 | 
| In re H.B. author | Dependency | Oct. 29, 2024 | 
| A.H. v. Tamalpais Union High School Dist. dissenting | Education | Sep. 25, 2024 | 
| Fox Paine & Co., LLC v. Twin City Fire Insurance Co. author | Insurance | Sep. 6, 2024 | 
| Greisman v. FCA US, LLC author | Civil Procedure | Aug. 6, 2024 | 
| Doe v. Uber Technologies, Inc. author | Civil Procedure | Jun. 25, 2024 | 
| Modification: Wood v. San Francisco Superior Court author | Civil Procedure | Mar. 19, 2024 | 
| Wood v. San Francisco Superior Court author | Civil Procedure | Mar. 15, 2024 | 
| Conservatorship of T.B. author | Civil Procedure | Feb. 27, 2024 | 
| Abney v. State Dept. of Health Care Services author | Administrative Agencies | Feb. 1, 2024 | 
| Tornai v. CSAA Insurance Exchange author | Insurance | Jan. 11, 2024 | 
| Vann v. City and County of San Francisco author | Workers' Compensation | Dec. 12, 2023 | 
| Bondgraham v. Superior Court (City of Oakland) author | Public Records Act | Sep. 26, 2023 | 
| In re V.C. author | Dependency | Sep. 6, 2023 | 
| Barrera v. Apple American Group LLC author | Arbitration | Sep. 1, 2023 | 
| Rosenberg-Wohl v. State Farm Fire and Casualty Co. author | Insurance | Jul. 12, 2023 | 
| Wong v. Stillwater Insurance Co. author | Insurance | Jul. 3, 2023 | 
| People v. Lipscomb author | Criminal Law and Procedure | Dec. 29, 2022 | 
| California-American Water Co. v. Marina Coast Water Dist. author | Administrative Agencies | Dec. 28, 2022 | 
| Jenkins v. Brandt-Hawley author | Anti-SLAPP | Dec. 28, 2022 | 
| People v. Monroe author | Criminal Law and Procedure | Nov. 17, 2022 | 
| Amiodarone Cases author | Torts | Nov. 4, 2022 | 
| Davis v. Shiekh Shoes, LLC author | Arbitration | Oct. 31, 2022 | 
| Tarrar Enterprises v. Associated Indemnity Corp. author | Civil Procedure | Sep. 23, 2022 | 
| John/Jane Doe v. McLaughlin author | Civil Procedure | Sep. 22, 2022 | 
| Apple Annie, LLC v. Oregon Mutual Ins. Co. author | Insurance | Sep. 6, 2022 | 
| Victaulic Co. v. American Home Assurance Co. author | Attorneys | Jun. 28, 2022 | 
| Tiburon Open Space Committee v. County of Marin author | Environmental Law | May 16, 2022 | 
| Lincoln v. Lopez author | Civil Procedure | Apr. 27, 2022 | 
| Artus v. Gramercy Towers Condominium Assn. author | Civil Procedure | Mar. 31, 2022 | 
| Pappas v. Chang author | Contracts | Mar. 7, 2022 | 
| George v. eBay, Inc. author | Contracts | Nov. 15, 2021 | 
| Moreci v. Scaffold Solutions, Inc. author | Attorneys | Oct. 20, 2021 | 
| People v. Bankers Insurance Co. author | Criminal Law and Procedure | Sep. 29, 2021 | 
| Korchemny v. Piterman author | Contracts | Sep. 21, 2021 | 
| In re Murray author | Civil Rights | Sep. 2, 2021 | 
| Alameda County Waste Management Authority v. Waste Connections US, Inc. et al. dissenting | Utilities | Aug. 20, 2021 | 
| In re I.S. author | Juveniles | Aug. 18, 2021 | 
| Pilliod v. Monsanto Co. dissenting | Torts | Aug. 11, 2021 | 
| Modification: Gateway Bank, F.S.B. v. Metaxas author | Remedies | Jun. 29, 2021 | 
| Gateway Bank, F.S.B. v. Metaxas author | Remedies | Jun. 7, 2021 | 
| Antonopoulos v. Mid-Century Insurance Co. author | Insurance | Apr. 29, 2021 | 
| In re Murray author | statutory_interpretation | Apr. 21, 2021 | 
| People v. Southard author | Criminal Law and Procedure | Mar. 26, 2021 | 
| Husain v. California Pacific Bank author | Real Property | Mar. 10, 2021 | 
| Chen v. Paypal author | Contracts | Mar. 4, 2021 | 
| Wilmot v. Contra Costa County Employee's Retirement Association author | statutory_interpretation | Feb. 9, 2021 | 
| Szarowicz v. Birenbaum author | Torts | Dec. 8, 2020 | 
| Olson v. Lyft, Inc. author | Arbitration | Nov. 2, 2020 | 
| Oakland Bulk and Oversized Terminal, LLC v. City of Oakland author | Anti-SLAPP | Sep. 21, 2020 | 
| Modification: Universal Home Improvement, Inc. v. Robertson author | Remedies | Jul. 23, 2020 | 
| Altizer v. Highsmith author | Civil Procedure | Jul. 20, 2020 | 
| Universal Home Improvement, Inc. v. Robertson author | Remedies | Jun. 29, 2020 | 
| Valero Refining Co. v. Bay Area Air Quality concurring | Environmental Law | Jun. 1, 2020 | 
| City of Warren Police and Fire Retirement System v. Natera Inc. concurring | Securities | Mar. 25, 2020 | 
| Coats v. New Haven Unified School Dist. concurring | Civil Procedure | Mar. 16, 2020 | 
| Modification: Sturgell v. Dept. of Fish and Wildlife author | Environmental Law | Jan. 6, 2020 | 
| Sturgell v. Dept. of Fish and Wildlife author | Environmental Law | Dec. 10, 2019 | 
| O'Grady v. Merchant Exchange Productions, Inc. author | Labor Law | Nov. 4, 2019 | 
| Davis v. TWC Dealer Group, Inc. author | Contracts | Nov. 1, 2019 | 
| Cal200, Inc., v. Apple Valley Unified School Dist. author | Education | Oct. 22, 2019 | 
| McClain v. Kissler dissenting | Civil Procedure | Sep. 4, 2019 | 
| Du-All Safety, LLC v. Superior Court author | Civil Procedure | Apr. 22, 2019 | 
| People v. Easter author | Criminal Law and Procedure | Apr. 15, 2019 | 
| Martinez v. Public Employees' Retirement System author | Government | Apr. 8, 2019 | 
| Richmond Compassionate Care Collective v. 7 Stars Holistic Foundation author | Anti-SLAPP | Mar. 18, 2019 | 
| Design Built Systems v. Sorokine author | statutory_interpretation | Mar. 1, 2019 | 
| Richmond Compassionate Care v. 7 Stars Holistic author | Anti-SLAPP | Feb. 25, 2019 | 
| Wilmot v. Contra Costa County Employees' Retirement Assn. author | Employment Law | Dec. 5, 2018 | 
| Modification: Fischer v. Fischer author | Family Law | May 14, 2018 | 
| Fischer v. Fischer author | Family Law | Apr. 24, 2018 | 
| Victaulic Co. v. American Home Assurance Co. author | Civil Procedure | Mar. 1, 2018 | 
| Central Valley Hospitalists v. Dignity Health author | Anti-SLAPP | Jan. 11, 2018 | 
| Turley v. Familian Corp. author | Torts | Dec. 27, 2017 | 
| City of Fontana et al. v. California Department of Tax and Fee Administration author | Administrative Agencies | Nov. 30, 2017 | 
| Medley Capital Corporation v. Security National Guaranty, Inc et al. author | Torts | Nov. 15, 2017 | 
| Denton v. City and County of San Francisco author | Civil Procedure | Oct. 31, 2017 | 
| People v. Lewelling author | Criminal Law and Procedure | Oct. 18, 2017 | 
| City of Fontana v. California Dept. of Tax and Fee Administration author | Administrative Agencies | Sep. 14, 2017 | 
| Cross v. Facebook author | Anti-SLAPP | Aug. 11, 2017 | 
| Rush v. White Corp. author | Civil Procedure | Aug. 1, 2017 | 
| In re Palmer author | Criminal Law and Procedure | Jul. 27, 2017 | 
Verdicts & Settlements
| Case Name | Topic | Role | Published | 
|---|---|---|---|
| Confidential | Insurance | judge | Jul. 13, 2004 | 
| Steve Keppert v. Heather Maria Lazarom and Pacific Sunrise Corporation, dba Pacific Valley Financial | Personal Injury (Vehicular) | judge | Nov. 15, 1997 | 
| Begnal, et al. v. Canfield & Association, Inc., et al. | Employment Law | judge | Oct. 18, 1997 | 
| Title | Court | Published | 
|---|---|---|
| The Heavy | 1st Appellate District, Division 2 (San Francisco) | May 13, 2021 | 
| From Pen-and-Paper Man to Internet Guru | 1st District Court of Appeal | Oct. 23, 2007 | 
| Case | Category | Published | 
|---|---|---|
| Birdsall v. Helfet author | Contracts | Aug. 12, 2025 | 
| Oakland Bulk and Oversized Terminal v. City of Oakland author | Contracts | Jun. 30, 2025 | 
| People v. Lewis author | Criminal Law and Procedure | Jun. 13, 2025 | 
| Medtronic USA v. California Dept. of Tax & Fee Admin. author | Tax | Apr. 17, 2025 | 
| People v. Hill author | Criminal Law and Procedure | Mar. 3, 2025 | 
| Watts v. Pneumo Abex author | Torts | Oct. 30, 2024 | 
| In re H.B. author | Dependency | Oct. 29, 2024 | 
| A.H. v. Tamalpais Union High School Dist. dissenting | Education | Sep. 25, 2024 | 
| Fox Paine & Co., LLC v. Twin City Fire Insurance Co. author | Insurance | Sep. 6, 2024 | 
| Greisman v. FCA US, LLC author | Civil Procedure | Aug. 6, 2024 | 
| Doe v. Uber Technologies, Inc. author | Civil Procedure | Jun. 25, 2024 | 
| Modification: Wood v. San Francisco Superior Court author | Civil Procedure | Mar. 19, 2024 | 
| Wood v. San Francisco Superior Court author | Civil Procedure | Mar. 15, 2024 | 
| Conservatorship of T.B. author | Civil Procedure | Feb. 27, 2024 | 
| Abney v. State Dept. of Health Care Services author | Administrative Agencies | Feb. 1, 2024 | 
| Tornai v. CSAA Insurance Exchange author | Insurance | Jan. 11, 2024 | 
| Vann v. City and County of San Francisco author | Workers' Compensation | Dec. 12, 2023 | 
| Bondgraham v. Superior Court (City of Oakland) author | Public Records Act | Sep. 26, 2023 | 
| In re V.C. author | Dependency | Sep. 6, 2023 | 
| Barrera v. Apple American Group LLC author | Arbitration | Sep. 1, 2023 | 
| Rosenberg-Wohl v. State Farm Fire and Casualty Co. author | Insurance | Jul. 12, 2023 | 
| Wong v. Stillwater Insurance Co. author | Insurance | Jul. 3, 2023 | 
| People v. Lipscomb author | Criminal Law and Procedure | Dec. 29, 2022 | 
| California-American Water Co. v. Marina Coast Water Dist. author | Administrative Agencies | Dec. 28, 2022 | 
| Jenkins v. Brandt-Hawley author | Anti-SLAPP | Dec. 28, 2022 | 
| People v. Monroe author | Criminal Law and Procedure | Nov. 17, 2022 | 
| Amiodarone Cases author | Torts | Nov. 4, 2022 | 
| Davis v. Shiekh Shoes, LLC author | Arbitration | Oct. 31, 2022 | 
| Tarrar Enterprises v. Associated Indemnity Corp. author | Civil Procedure | Sep. 23, 2022 | 
| John/Jane Doe v. McLaughlin author | Civil Procedure | Sep. 22, 2022 | 
| Apple Annie, LLC v. Oregon Mutual Ins. Co. author | Insurance | Sep. 6, 2022 | 
| Victaulic Co. v. American Home Assurance Co. author | Attorneys | Jun. 28, 2022 | 
| Tiburon Open Space Committee v. County of Marin author | Environmental Law | May 16, 2022 | 
| Lincoln v. Lopez author | Civil Procedure | Apr. 27, 2022 | 
| Artus v. Gramercy Towers Condominium Assn. author | Civil Procedure | Mar. 31, 2022 | 
| Pappas v. Chang author | Contracts | Mar. 7, 2022 | 
| George v. eBay, Inc. author | Contracts | Nov. 15, 2021 | 
| Moreci v. Scaffold Solutions, Inc. author | Attorneys | Oct. 20, 2021 | 
| People v. Bankers Insurance Co. author | Criminal Law and Procedure | Sep. 29, 2021 | 
| Korchemny v. Piterman author | Contracts | Sep. 21, 2021 | 
| In re Murray author | Civil Rights | Sep. 2, 2021 | 
| Alameda County Waste Management Authority v. Waste Connections US, Inc. et al. dissenting | Utilities | Aug. 20, 2021 | 
| In re I.S. author | Juveniles | Aug. 18, 2021 | 
| Pilliod v. Monsanto Co. dissenting | Torts | Aug. 11, 2021 | 
| Modification: Gateway Bank, F.S.B. v. Metaxas author | Remedies | Jun. 29, 2021 | 
| Gateway Bank, F.S.B. v. Metaxas author | Remedies | Jun. 7, 2021 | 
| Antonopoulos v. Mid-Century Insurance Co. author | Insurance | Apr. 29, 2021 | 
| In re Murray author | statutory_interpretation | Apr. 21, 2021 | 
| People v. Southard author | Criminal Law and Procedure | Mar. 26, 2021 | 
| Husain v. California Pacific Bank author | Real Property | Mar. 10, 2021 | 
| Chen v. Paypal author | Contracts | Mar. 4, 2021 | 
| Wilmot v. Contra Costa County Employee's Retirement Association author | statutory_interpretation | Feb. 9, 2021 | 
| Szarowicz v. Birenbaum author | Torts | Dec. 8, 2020 | 
| Olson v. Lyft, Inc. author | Arbitration | Nov. 2, 2020 | 
| Oakland Bulk and Oversized Terminal, LLC v. City of Oakland author | Anti-SLAPP | Sep. 21, 2020 | 
| Modification: Universal Home Improvement, Inc. v. Robertson author | Remedies | Jul. 23, 2020 | 
| Altizer v. Highsmith author | Civil Procedure | Jul. 20, 2020 | 
| Universal Home Improvement, Inc. v. Robertson author | Remedies | Jun. 29, 2020 | 
| Valero Refining Co. v. Bay Area Air Quality concurring | Environmental Law | Jun. 1, 2020 | 
| City of Warren Police and Fire Retirement System v. Natera Inc. concurring | Securities | Mar. 25, 2020 | 
| Coats v. New Haven Unified School Dist. concurring | Civil Procedure | Mar. 16, 2020 | 
| Modification: Sturgell v. Dept. of Fish and Wildlife author | Environmental Law | Jan. 6, 2020 | 
| Sturgell v. Dept. of Fish and Wildlife author | Environmental Law | Dec. 10, 2019 | 
| O'Grady v. Merchant Exchange Productions, Inc. author | Labor Law | Nov. 4, 2019 | 
| Davis v. TWC Dealer Group, Inc. author | Contracts | Nov. 1, 2019 | 
| Cal200, Inc., v. Apple Valley Unified School Dist. author | Education | Oct. 22, 2019 | 
| McClain v. Kissler dissenting | Civil Procedure | Sep. 4, 2019 | 
| Du-All Safety, LLC v. Superior Court author | Civil Procedure | Apr. 22, 2019 | 
| People v. Easter author | Criminal Law and Procedure | Apr. 15, 2019 | 
| Martinez v. Public Employees' Retirement System author | Government | Apr. 8, 2019 | 
| Richmond Compassionate Care Collective v. 7 Stars Holistic Foundation author | Anti-SLAPP | Mar. 18, 2019 | 
| Design Built Systems v. Sorokine author | statutory_interpretation | Mar. 1, 2019 | 
| Richmond Compassionate Care v. 7 Stars Holistic author | Anti-SLAPP | Feb. 25, 2019 | 
| Wilmot v. Contra Costa County Employees' Retirement Assn. author | Employment Law | Dec. 5, 2018 | 
| Modification: Fischer v. Fischer author | Family Law | May 14, 2018 | 
| Fischer v. Fischer author | Family Law | Apr. 24, 2018 | 
| Victaulic Co. v. American Home Assurance Co. author | Civil Procedure | Mar. 1, 2018 | 
| Central Valley Hospitalists v. Dignity Health author | Anti-SLAPP | Jan. 11, 2018 | 
| Turley v. Familian Corp. author | Torts | Dec. 27, 2017 | 
| City of Fontana et al. v. California Department of Tax and Fee Administration author | Administrative Agencies | Nov. 30, 2017 | 
| Medley Capital Corporation v. Security National Guaranty, Inc et al. author | Torts | Nov. 15, 2017 | 
| Denton v. City and County of San Francisco author | Civil Procedure | Oct. 31, 2017 | 
| People v. Lewelling author | Criminal Law and Procedure | Oct. 18, 2017 | 
| City of Fontana v. California Dept. of Tax and Fee Administration author | Administrative Agencies | Sep. 14, 2017 | 
| Cross v. Facebook author | Anti-SLAPP | Aug. 11, 2017 | 
| Rush v. White Corp. author | Civil Procedure | Aug. 1, 2017 | 
| In re Palmer author | Criminal Law and Procedure | Jul. 27, 2017 | 
| Case Name | Topic | Role | Published | 
|---|---|---|---|
| Confidential | Insurance | judge | Jul. 13, 2004 | 
| Steve Keppert v. Heather Maria Lazarom and Pacific Sunrise Corporation, dba Pacific Valley Financial | Personal Injury (Vehicular) | judge | Nov. 15, 1997 | 
| Begnal, et al. v. Canfield & Association, Inc., et al. | Employment Law | judge | Oct. 18, 1997 | 
 

 
