For reprint rights or to purchase a copy of your Daily Journal photo, email Jeremy_Ellis@dailyjournal.com for prices or call 213-229-5424.

To buy more copies, call 866-531-1492 or email subscribe@dailyjournal.com
This is the property of the Daily Journal Corporation and fully protected by copyright. It is made available only to Daily Journal subscribers for personal or collaborative purposes and may not be distributed, reproduced, modified, stored or transferred without written permission. Please click "Reprint" to order presentation-ready copies to distribute to clients or use in commercial marketing materials or for permission to post on a website. and copyright (showing year of publication) at the bottom.

Consuelo B. Marshall

See more on Consuelo B. Marshall

Senior District Judge
USDC Central District of California
Western Division / First Street Federal Courthouse
Days: M-F Courtroom/Floor: 8B

350 W 1st St #4311
Los Angeles , CA 90012-4565
(213) 894-0189





Judicial Profiles
Title Court Published
District Judge Consuelo B. Marshall U.S. District Court of California, Central District Nov. 18, 2002

Rulings
Case Category Published
Amended Opinion: CoStar Group v. Commercial Real Estate Exchange
affirmed
 Antitrust Sep. 5, 2025
CoStar Group v. Commercial Real Estate Exchange
affirmed
 Antitrust Jun. 23, 2025
Moving Oxnard Forward Inc. v. Ascension
reversed and remanded
 Constitutional Law Dec. 20, 2024
Kaweah Delta Health Care District v. Becerra
vacated in whole or part
 Administrative Agencies Dec. 11, 2024
Black Lives Matter Los Angeles v. Los Angeles
vacated and remanded
 Civil Procedure Sep. 5, 2024
Amended Opinion: Rieman v. Vasquez
affirmed
 Immunity Apr. 2, 2024
Rieman v. Vasquez
affirmed
 Immunity Mar. 5, 2024
Scanlon v. County of Los Angeles
reversed in part
 Civil Rights Feb. 2, 2024
Amended Opinion: U.S. Wholesale Outlet & Distribution v. Innovation Ventures, LLC
reversed in part
 Antitrust Dec. 22, 2023
U.S. Wholesale Outlet & Distribution V. Innovation Ventures, LLC
reversed in part
 Antitrust Jul. 20, 2023
Reno v. Davis
affirmed
 Criminal Law and Procedure Aug. 19, 2022
Produce Pay Inc. v. Izguerra Produce Inc.
reversed and remanded
 Commercial Law Jul. 8, 2022
McDougall v. County of Ventura
reversed and remanded
 Constitutional Law Jan. 21, 2022
Bell v. Wilmot Storage Services
reversed and remanded
 Copyright Sep. 10, 2021
Rojas v. Federal Aviation Administration
vacated in whole or part
 statutory_interpretation Mar. 3, 2021
Amended Opinion: Frlekin v. Apple
author
 Labor Law Oct. 30, 2020
Rodriguez v. Newsom
affirmed
 Civil Rights Sep. 9, 2020
Frlekin v. Apple
author
 Labor Law Sep. 3, 2020
Allied Professionals Insurance Company v. Anglesey
affirmed
 Constitutional Law Mar. 13, 2020
U.S. v. Exxon Mobil Corp.
reversed and remanded
 Environmental Law Dec. 10, 2019
USSEC v. Feng
affirmed
 Securities Aug. 26, 2019
Amended Opinion: Rojas v. FAA
reversed and remanded
 Government Jun. 19, 2019
Rojas v. FAA
reversed and remanded
 Government Apr. 25, 2019
Xue Lu v. United States
vacated and remanded
 Government Apr. 18, 2019
Lee v. City of Los Angeles
affirmed
 Civil Rights Nov. 20, 2018
Rodriguez v. Cruz
affirmed
 Civil Rights May 31, 2018
Williby v. Aetna Life Insurance Co.
vacated and remanded
 Civil Procedure Aug. 16, 2017

Verdicts & Settlements
Case Name Topic Role Published
Rachel Scanlon, et al. v. County of Los Angeles, et al. Civil Rights judge Sep. 4, 2025
Buck G. Woodall a.k.a. Buck Woodall, an individual v. The Walt Disney Company; Walt Disney Pictures; Walt Disney Animation Studios; Disney Enterprises Inc.; Disney Consumer Products Inc.; Disney Consumer Products & Interactive Media Inc.; Walt Disney Direct-to-Consumer & International; Disney Book Group LLC; Disney Interactive Studios Inc.; Disney Store USA LLC; Disney Shopping Inc; Buena Vista Home Entertainment Inc.; Buena Vista Books Inc.; Mandeville Films Inc.; Jenny Marchick; Pamela Ribon, and Does 1-10, inclusive Intellectual Property judge Jun. 6, 2025
David Zuniga v. City of Los Angeles, Chief Michael Moore, Jorge Rodriguez, Daniel Bunch, Miguel Zendejas, Aaron Green, Jesus Garcia, Gregory Sayers, and Does 1 to 10 Civil Rights judge Feb. 14, 2025
International Medical Devices Inc., et al. v. Robert Cornell, M.D.; Robert J. Cornell, M.D., P.A.; Augmenta LLC; Augmenta Investors LLC; Cornell Cosmetic Urology LLC; David Louis Nichols; Huck Medical Technologies, Inc.; Hans Mische; Hans Mische LLC; Run Wang, M.D.; and Richard B. Finger Intellectual Property judge Jul. 19, 2024
Call Delivery Systems LLC v. Daryl Morgan, Carl Haven Partners LLC Intellectual Property judge Mar. 15, 2024
Mayra Aranda v. Nissan Motor Acceptance Corporation; Experian Information Solutions Inc.; Trans Union LLC; Equifax Information Services LLC Consumer Law judge Dec. 1, 2023
Kaweah Delta Health Care District dba Kaweah Delta Medical Center et al. v. Xavier Becerra, Acting Secretary, United States Department of Health and Human Services, in his official capacity Government judge Apr. 21, 2023
Richard Garries, Andrew Ybarra, individually and on behalf of all others similarly situated v. Louis Milusnic, in his capacity as Warden of Lompoc, et al. Civil Rights judge Jan. 6, 2023
Sandra Parziale, as co-trustee of the Parziale Family Trust, on behalf of herself and all others similarly situated v. Patrick Nelson; Nelson Partners LLC; NP Skyloft ST LLC, NP Skyloft JV LLC, Aco Skyloft Manager LLC, Axonic Credit Opportunities Master Fund LP, AXSPV LLC Series NB CRE Lender, AXSPV LLC Series SBL CRE Lender, AXSPV LLC Series Aco CRE Lender, Axonic Capital LLC, Clayton Degiancinto, and Does 1 through 50, inclusive Securities judge Dec. 23, 2022
Assem Mussarova, et al. v. Merrick B. Garland Immigration judge Sep. 2, 2022
Chris Hashem, individually and on behalf of all others similarly situated v. NMC Health PLC, Prasanth Manghat, Khalifa Bin Butti, Prashanth Shenoy, H.J. Mark Tompkins, B.R. Shetty Securities judge Jul. 8, 2022
Glen Barnes, individually and on behalf of all others similarly situated v. Edison International, Southern California Edison Company, Pedro J. Pizarro, Maria Rigatti, Kevin M. Payne, William M. Petmecky III, Theodore F. Craver Jr., and William James Scillacci, SCE Trust VI, Connie J. Erickson, J.P. Morgan Securities LLC, Morgan Stanley & Co. LLC, RBC Capital Markets, LLC, Wells Fargo Securities, LLC, Citigroup Global Markets, Inc., Mizuho Securities USA LLC, MUFG Securities Americas Inc., PNC Capital Markets LLC, TD Securities LLC, U.S. Bancorp Investments, Inc., Academy Securities LLC, U.S. Bancorp Investments, Inc., Academy Securities, Inc., C.L. King & Associates LLC, and Samuel A. Ramirez & Company, Inc . Securities judge Jan. 28, 2022
United States of America v. American Honda Finance Corporation Torts judge Oct. 22, 2021
U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission v. Cardinal Health 200, LLC dba Cardinal Health; Howroyd-Wright Employment Agency Inc. dba Appleone Employment Services, and Does 1-10, inclusive Employment Law judge Aug. 6, 2021
Monster Energy Company v. Integrated Supply Network LLC Intellectual Property judge Jul. 16, 2021
Lori Ibrahim, et al. v. County of Los Angeles, et al. Civil Rights judge May 21, 2021
Hani Yasin, an individual; and minor plaintiffs S.A., S.B., S.C., by and through their Guardian ad Litem, Hani Yasin v. County of Los Angeles, a public entity; Los Angeles Department of Children and Family Services, a subdivision of the County of Los Angeles; Carla Alvarenga, an individual; Jessica Marcellous-Payne, an individual; Sarah Wong, an individual; Gregory Chase, an individual; Nora Jordan, an individual; Nichole Wade, an individual; Adrienne Snowden, an individual; Leroy Cloud, Jr, an individual; and Does 1- 50, Civil Rights judge Feb. 12, 2021
Donald McDougall; Juliana Garcia; Second Amendment Foundation; California Gun Rights Foundation; Firearms Policy Coalition Inc. v. County of Ventura, California; Bill Ayub, in his official capacity; William T. Foley, in his official capacity; Robert Levin, in his official capacity; Ventura County Public Health Care Agency Constitutional Law judge Dec. 11, 2020
U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission v. Jet Propulsion Laboratory, Does 1-100, inclusive Employment Law judge Aug. 21, 2020
Environmental Defense Center v. Pacific Coast Energy Company LP Environmental Law judge May 8, 2020
Alex Aguilar Jr., and P.A., by and through her Guardian ad Litem, Florence Ahumada, and The Estate of Alex Aguilar Sr. v. City of Los Angeles, Chief Charlie Beck, and Does 1-10, inclusive Civil Rights judge Nov. 22, 2019
Matt Salnick v. Ameron Pole Products LLC Environmental Law judge Jul. 5, 2019
Farhad Safinia v. Voltage Pictures LLC, a California limited liability company; Voltage Productions LLC, a Nevada limited liability company; Christchurch Productions DAC, an Ireland designated activity company; Nicolas Chartier, an individual; and Does 1 through 100, inclusive Intellectual Property judge Apr. 19, 2019
Shannon Paine v. City of Pismo Beach, et al. Civil Rights judge Jul. 29, 2003
Minder Music Ltd. v. Interscope Records Inc., Aftermath Entertainment, Universal Music & Video Distribution Inc., Andre Young, et al. Entertainment Law judge May 28, 2003
Michael Gallagher v. City of West Covina, et al. Civil Rights judge Feb. 4, 2003
Brenda Garcia v. Pacific Telesis Employment Law judge Oct. 12, 2000
Express Textile Consultants Inc. v. General Accident Insurance judge May 27, 2000
Tino Sorchini v. City of Covina Civil Rights judge Aug. 28, 1999
JEC International Corporation v. Chaka Khan, Khantagious Entertainment, Inc. and Tammy McCrary Entertainment Law judge Sep. 19, 1998
Dearing v. Crowley Marine Services Maritime Law judge Aug. 22, 1998
Allen Alevy dba A&D MiniMart v. Alliance General Insurance Company Insurance judge Jun. 13, 1998
Confidential Personal Injury (Vehicular) judge Nov. 8, 1997
Estate of Jerry Alexander v. County of Los Angeles and Orlando Atencio Civil Rights judge Apr. 12, 1997
Confidential Civil Rights judge Mar. 22, 1997
Applied Industrial Materials Corporation v. Ultramar, Inc. Business Law judge Feb. 22, 1997
Confidential Civil Rights judge Jan. 11, 1997
Confidential Civil Rights judge Sep. 28, 1996
Classic Corporation v. American National Watermattress Corporation, et al. Antitrust judge Aug. 31, 1996
Confidential Civil Rights judge Jun. 15, 1996
Merle Demroff v. State of California, et al. Employment Law judge May 4, 1996
Thomas E. Snooks v. SRS Technologies, Systems Engineering Technology Associates Corporation, SETAC, Inc., Mohindar Sandhu Securities judge Feb. 4, 1995
Kelly Escobar v. James Scutella, et al. Civil Rights judge Sep. 10, 1994
Confidential Civil Rights judge Sep. 10, 1994
Silver Sage Partners, Ltd., et al. v. City of Desert Hot Springs, et al. judge Jul. 23, 1994
Anthony Mee v. City of Los Angeles Personal Injury (Non-Vehicular) judge Feb. 26, 1994
Confidential Personal Injury (Non-Vehicular) judge Oct. 30, 1993
Title Court Published
District Judge Consuelo B. Marshall U.S. District Court of California, Central District Nov. 18, 2002
Case Category Published
Amended Opinion: CoStar Group v. Commercial Real Estate Exchange
affirmed
 Antitrust Sep. 5, 2025
CoStar Group v. Commercial Real Estate Exchange
affirmed
 Antitrust Jun. 23, 2025
Moving Oxnard Forward Inc. v. Ascension
reversed and remanded
 Constitutional Law Dec. 20, 2024
Kaweah Delta Health Care District v. Becerra
vacated in whole or part
 Administrative Agencies Dec. 11, 2024
Black Lives Matter Los Angeles v. Los Angeles
vacated and remanded
 Civil Procedure Sep. 5, 2024
Amended Opinion: Rieman v. Vasquez
affirmed
 Immunity Apr. 2, 2024
Rieman v. Vasquez
affirmed
 Immunity Mar. 5, 2024
Scanlon v. County of Los Angeles
reversed in part
 Civil Rights Feb. 2, 2024
Amended Opinion: U.S. Wholesale Outlet & Distribution v. Innovation Ventures, LLC
reversed in part
 Antitrust Dec. 22, 2023
U.S. Wholesale Outlet & Distribution V. Innovation Ventures, LLC
reversed in part
 Antitrust Jul. 20, 2023
Reno v. Davis
affirmed
 Criminal Law and Procedure Aug. 19, 2022
Produce Pay Inc. v. Izguerra Produce Inc.
reversed and remanded
 Commercial Law Jul. 8, 2022
McDougall v. County of Ventura
reversed and remanded
 Constitutional Law Jan. 21, 2022
Bell v. Wilmot Storage Services
reversed and remanded
 Copyright Sep. 10, 2021
Rojas v. Federal Aviation Administration
vacated in whole or part
 statutory_interpretation Mar. 3, 2021
Amended Opinion: Frlekin v. Apple
author
 Labor Law Oct. 30, 2020
Rodriguez v. Newsom
affirmed
 Civil Rights Sep. 9, 2020
Frlekin v. Apple
author
 Labor Law Sep. 3, 2020
Allied Professionals Insurance Company v. Anglesey
affirmed
 Constitutional Law Mar. 13, 2020
U.S. v. Exxon Mobil Corp.
reversed and remanded
 Environmental Law Dec. 10, 2019
USSEC v. Feng
affirmed
 Securities Aug. 26, 2019
Amended Opinion: Rojas v. FAA
reversed and remanded
 Government Jun. 19, 2019
Rojas v. FAA
reversed and remanded
 Government Apr. 25, 2019
Xue Lu v. United States
vacated and remanded
 Government Apr. 18, 2019
Lee v. City of Los Angeles
affirmed
 Civil Rights Nov. 20, 2018
Rodriguez v. Cruz
affirmed
 Civil Rights May 31, 2018
Williby v. Aetna Life Insurance Co.
vacated and remanded
 Civil Procedure Aug. 16, 2017
Case Name Topic Role Published
Rachel Scanlon, et al. v. County of Los Angeles, et al. Civil Rights judge Sep. 4, 2025
Buck G. Woodall a.k.a. Buck Woodall, an individual v. The Walt Disney Company; Walt Disney Pictures; Walt Disney Animation Studios; Disney Enterprises Inc.; Disney Consumer Products Inc.; Disney Consumer Products & Interactive Media Inc.; Walt Disney Direct-to-Consumer & International; Disney Book Group LLC; Disney Interactive Studios Inc.; Disney Store USA LLC; Disney Shopping Inc; Buena Vista Home Entertainment Inc.; Buena Vista Books Inc.; Mandeville Films Inc.; Jenny Marchick; Pamela Ribon, and Does 1-10, inclusive Intellectual Property judge Jun. 6, 2025
David Zuniga v. City of Los Angeles, Chief Michael Moore, Jorge Rodriguez, Daniel Bunch, Miguel Zendejas, Aaron Green, Jesus Garcia, Gregory Sayers, and Does 1 to 10 Civil Rights judge Feb. 14, 2025
International Medical Devices Inc., et al. v. Robert Cornell, M.D.; Robert J. Cornell, M.D., P.A.; Augmenta LLC; Augmenta Investors LLC; Cornell Cosmetic Urology LLC; David Louis Nichols; Huck Medical Technologies, Inc.; Hans Mische; Hans Mische LLC; Run Wang, M.D.; and Richard B. Finger Intellectual Property judge Jul. 19, 2024
Call Delivery Systems LLC v. Daryl Morgan, Carl Haven Partners LLC Intellectual Property judge Mar. 15, 2024
Mayra Aranda v. Nissan Motor Acceptance Corporation; Experian Information Solutions Inc.; Trans Union LLC; Equifax Information Services LLC Consumer Law judge Dec. 1, 2023
Kaweah Delta Health Care District dba Kaweah Delta Medical Center et al. v. Xavier Becerra, Acting Secretary, United States Department of Health and Human Services, in his official capacity Government judge Apr. 21, 2023
Richard Garries, Andrew Ybarra, individually and on behalf of all others similarly situated v. Louis Milusnic, in his capacity as Warden of Lompoc, et al. Civil Rights judge Jan. 6, 2023
Sandra Parziale, as co-trustee of the Parziale Family Trust, on behalf of herself and all others similarly situated v. Patrick Nelson; Nelson Partners LLC; NP Skyloft ST LLC, NP Skyloft JV LLC, Aco Skyloft Manager LLC, Axonic Credit Opportunities Master Fund LP, AXSPV LLC Series NB CRE Lender, AXSPV LLC Series SBL CRE Lender, AXSPV LLC Series Aco CRE Lender, Axonic Capital LLC, Clayton Degiancinto, and Does 1 through 50, inclusive Securities judge Dec. 23, 2022
Assem Mussarova, et al. v. Merrick B. Garland Immigration judge Sep. 2, 2022
Chris Hashem, individually and on behalf of all others similarly situated v. NMC Health PLC, Prasanth Manghat, Khalifa Bin Butti, Prashanth Shenoy, H.J. Mark Tompkins, B.R. Shetty Securities judge Jul. 8, 2022
Glen Barnes, individually and on behalf of all others similarly situated v. Edison International, Southern California Edison Company, Pedro J. Pizarro, Maria Rigatti, Kevin M. Payne, William M. Petmecky III, Theodore F. Craver Jr., and William James Scillacci, SCE Trust VI, Connie J. Erickson, J.P. Morgan Securities LLC, Morgan Stanley & Co. LLC, RBC Capital Markets, LLC, Wells Fargo Securities, LLC, Citigroup Global Markets, Inc., Mizuho Securities USA LLC, MUFG Securities Americas Inc., PNC Capital Markets LLC, TD Securities LLC, U.S. Bancorp Investments, Inc., Academy Securities LLC, U.S. Bancorp Investments, Inc., Academy Securities, Inc., C.L. King & Associates LLC, and Samuel A. Ramirez & Company, Inc . Securities judge Jan. 28, 2022
United States of America v. American Honda Finance Corporation Torts judge Oct. 22, 2021
U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission v. Cardinal Health 200, LLC dba Cardinal Health; Howroyd-Wright Employment Agency Inc. dba Appleone Employment Services, and Does 1-10, inclusive Employment Law judge Aug. 6, 2021
Monster Energy Company v. Integrated Supply Network LLC Intellectual Property judge Jul. 16, 2021
Lori Ibrahim, et al. v. County of Los Angeles, et al. Civil Rights judge May 21, 2021
Hani Yasin, an individual; and minor plaintiffs S.A., S.B., S.C., by and through their Guardian ad Litem, Hani Yasin v. County of Los Angeles, a public entity; Los Angeles Department of Children and Family Services, a subdivision of the County of Los Angeles; Carla Alvarenga, an individual; Jessica Marcellous-Payne, an individual; Sarah Wong, an individual; Gregory Chase, an individual; Nora Jordan, an individual; Nichole Wade, an individual; Adrienne Snowden, an individual; Leroy Cloud, Jr, an individual; and Does 1- 50, Civil Rights judge Feb. 12, 2021
Donald McDougall; Juliana Garcia; Second Amendment Foundation; California Gun Rights Foundation; Firearms Policy Coalition Inc. v. County of Ventura, California; Bill Ayub, in his official capacity; William T. Foley, in his official capacity; Robert Levin, in his official capacity; Ventura County Public Health Care Agency Constitutional Law judge Dec. 11, 2020
U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission v. Jet Propulsion Laboratory, Does 1-100, inclusive Employment Law judge Aug. 21, 2020
Environmental Defense Center v. Pacific Coast Energy Company LP Environmental Law judge May 8, 2020
Alex Aguilar Jr., and P.A., by and through her Guardian ad Litem, Florence Ahumada, and The Estate of Alex Aguilar Sr. v. City of Los Angeles, Chief Charlie Beck, and Does 1-10, inclusive Civil Rights judge Nov. 22, 2019
Matt Salnick v. Ameron Pole Products LLC Environmental Law judge Jul. 5, 2019
Farhad Safinia v. Voltage Pictures LLC, a California limited liability company; Voltage Productions LLC, a Nevada limited liability company; Christchurch Productions DAC, an Ireland designated activity company; Nicolas Chartier, an individual; and Does 1 through 100, inclusive Intellectual Property judge Apr. 19, 2019
Shannon Paine v. City of Pismo Beach, et al. Civil Rights judge Jul. 29, 2003
Minder Music Ltd. v. Interscope Records Inc., Aftermath Entertainment, Universal Music & Video Distribution Inc., Andre Young, et al. Entertainment Law judge May 28, 2003
Michael Gallagher v. City of West Covina, et al. Civil Rights judge Feb. 4, 2003
Brenda Garcia v. Pacific Telesis Employment Law judge Oct. 12, 2000
Express Textile Consultants Inc. v. General Accident Insurance judge May 27, 2000
Tino Sorchini v. City of Covina Civil Rights judge Aug. 28, 1999
JEC International Corporation v. Chaka Khan, Khantagious Entertainment, Inc. and Tammy McCrary Entertainment Law judge Sep. 19, 1998
Dearing v. Crowley Marine Services Maritime Law judge Aug. 22, 1998
Allen Alevy dba A&D MiniMart v. Alliance General Insurance Company Insurance judge Jun. 13, 1998
Confidential Personal Injury (Vehicular) judge Nov. 8, 1997
Estate of Jerry Alexander v. County of Los Angeles and Orlando Atencio Civil Rights judge Apr. 12, 1997
Confidential Civil Rights judge Mar. 22, 1997
Applied Industrial Materials Corporation v. Ultramar, Inc. Business Law judge Feb. 22, 1997
Confidential Civil Rights judge Jan. 11, 1997
Confidential Civil Rights judge Sep. 28, 1996
Classic Corporation v. American National Watermattress Corporation, et al. Antitrust judge Aug. 31, 1996
Confidential Civil Rights judge Jun. 15, 1996
Merle Demroff v. State of California, et al. Employment Law judge May 4, 1996
Thomas E. Snooks v. SRS Technologies, Systems Engineering Technology Associates Corporation, SETAC, Inc., Mohindar Sandhu Securities judge Feb. 4, 1995
Kelly Escobar v. James Scutella, et al. Civil Rights judge Sep. 10, 1994
Confidential Civil Rights judge Sep. 10, 1994
Silver Sage Partners, Ltd., et al. v. City of Desert Hot Springs, et al. judge Jul. 23, 1994
Anthony Mee v. City of Los Angeles Personal Injury (Non-Vehicular) judge Feb. 26, 1994
Confidential Personal Injury (Non-Vehicular) judge Oct. 30, 1993
By using our website, you agree to our use of cookies in accordance with our cookie policy. You can learn more about how we use cookies by reviewing our Privacy Policy here.