 
Associate Justice
California Courts of Appeal
1st Appellate District, Division 2
Department/Division:
2
350 McAllister St.
San Francisco , CA 94102-3600
(415) 865-7300
Appointed to the 1st District Court of Appeal by Gov. Jerry Brown, 2014; judge, San Francisco County Superior Court, 2005-14; partner, Morrison & Foerster, 1996-2005; chief assistant district attorney, San Francisco, 1996; partner, Howard Rice, 1992-96; assistant U.S. attorney, Northern District of California, 1987-92; partner, Howard Rice, 1986-87; associate, Howard Rice, 1981-86; clerk, 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeal Judge Charles M. Merrill, 1980-81
Harvard Law School, 1980
| Title | Court | Published | 
|---|---|---|
| The Appeal of Appeals | 1st District, Division 2 (San Francisco) | Jul. 13, 2021 | 
| Good and Ready | San Francisco County Superior Court | May 11, 2008 | 
| Case | Category | Published | 
|---|---|---|
| People v. Warner author | Criminal Law and Procedure | Oct. 22, 2025 | 
| People v. Krueger author | Criminal Law and Procedure | Oct. 22, 2025 | 
| People v. Dain author | Criminal Law and Procedure | Oct. 15, 2025 | 
| Solano County Orderly Growth Committee v. City of Fairfield author | Municipal Law | Aug. 29, 2025 | 
| International Currency Technologies v. ICT, Inc. author | Remedies | Jun. 30, 2025 | 
| Applegate v. Carrington Foreclosure Services, LLC author | Real Property | Jun. 27, 2025 | 
| Rose v. Hobby Lobby Stores author | Employment Law | May 15, 2025 | 
| Koi Nation of Northern California v. City of Clearlake author | Native American Affairs | Mar. 17, 2025 | 
| People v. Bravo author | Criminal Law and Procedure | Jan. 8, 2025 | 
| People v. Davis author | Criminal Law and Procedure | Dec. 19, 2024 | 
| People v. Royal author | Criminal Law and Procedure | Oct. 24, 2024 | 
| Bath v. State of California author | Government | Oct. 24, 2024 | 
| A.H. v. Tamalpais Union High School Dist. author | Education | Sep. 25, 2024 | 
| Nassiri v. City of Lafayette author | Environmental Law | Jul. 18, 2024 | 
| People v. Morales author | Criminal Law and Procedure | Jun. 21, 2024 | 
| Williams v. J-M Manufacturing Company author | Torts | May 23, 2024 | 
| Kime v. Dignity Health, Inc. author | Health Care | Apr. 26, 2024 | 
| People v. Dain author | Criminal Law and Procedure | Jan. 31, 2024 | 
| People v. Underwood author | Criminal Law and Procedure | Jan. 30, 2024 | 
| People v. Ponder author | Criminal Law and Procedure | Oct. 26, 2023 | 
| People v. Narro author | Criminal Law and Procedure | Sep. 8, 2023 | 
| Marriage of Hearn author | Family Law | Aug. 11, 2023 | 
| Doe v. CFR Enterprises, Inc. author | Torts | Jul. 28, 2023 | 
| In re Damari Y. author | Dependency | Jun. 19, 2023 | 
| McKneely v. Superior Court (People) author | Criminal Law and Procedure | May 26, 2023 | 
| Jack v. Ring LLC author | Arbitration | May 26, 2023 | 
| In re Jonathan C.M. author | Dependency | May 24, 2023 | 
| Gola v. University of San Francisco dissenting | Employment Law | Apr. 14, 2023 | 
| Ruegg & Ellsworth v. City of Berkeley author | Civil Procedure | Mar. 14, 2023 | 
| People v. Oliva author | Criminal Law and Procedure | Mar. 10, 2023 | 
| Gostev v. Skillz Platform author | Arbitration | Feb. 28, 2023 | 
| Degala v. John Stewart Company author | Torts | Feb. 8, 2023 | 
| People v. Ornelas author | Criminal Law and Procedure | Jan. 31, 2023 | 
| Sarah K. v. Superior Court (Sonoma County Human Services Department) author | Dependency | Jan. 17, 2023 | 
| Doe v. Massage Envy Franchising, LLC author | Arbitration | Dec. 29, 2022 | 
| Doe v. Finke author | Constitutional Law | Dec. 22, 2022 | 
| Modification: In re Foster author | Criminal Law and Procedure | Dec. 2, 2022 | 
| In re Foster author | Criminal Law and Procedure | Nov. 2, 2022 | 
| Sarkany v. West author | Civil Procedure | Aug. 31, 2022 | 
| People v. Caparaz author | Criminal Law and Procedure | Jul. 1, 2022 | 
| Turo v. Superior Court (People) author | Business Law | Jun. 29, 2022 | 
| People v. Padilla-Martel author | Constitutional Law | May 3, 2022 | 
| Wong v. Restoration Robotics author | Securities | May 2, 2022 | 
| Modification: Gajanan v. City and County of San Francisco author | Tax | Apr. 28, 2022 | 
| Gajanan v. City and County of San Francisco author | Tax | Apr. 26, 2022 | 
| People v. Pantoja author | Criminal Law and Procedure | Apr. 14, 2022 | 
| In re Cesar G. author | Juveniles | Feb. 14, 2022 | 
| Hutcheson v. Superior Court (UBS Financial Services) author | Employment Law | Feb. 9, 2022 | 
| People v. James author | Criminal Law and Procedure | Nov. 1, 2021 | 
| Doe v. The Regents of the University of California author | Administrative Agencies | Oct. 21, 2021 | 
| Doe v. The Regents of the University of California author | Administrative Agencies | Oct. 21, 2021 | 
| Pilliod v. Monsanto Co. author | Torts | Aug. 11, 2021 | 
| People v. Bankers Insurance Co. author | Criminal Law and Procedure | Jun. 11, 2021 | 
| People v. Clotfelter author | Criminal Law and Procedure | Jun. 4, 2021 | 
| People v. McInnis author | Criminal Law and Procedure | May 3, 2021 | 
| People v. McCloud author | Criminal Law and Procedure | Apr. 14, 2021 | 
| In re R.A. author | Dependency | Mar. 15, 2021 | 
| People v. Hall author | Criminal Law and Procedure | Nov. 27, 2020 | 
| Denny v. Arntz author | Government | Oct. 16, 2020 | 
| Carter v. Pulte Home Corporation concurring | Insurance | Jul. 24, 2020 | 
| Modification: Fadeeff v. State Farm General Insurance Co. author | Civil Procedure | Jul. 2, 2020 | 
| Eghtesad v. State Farm General Insurance Company author | Civil Procedure | Jul. 1, 2020 | 
| Fadeeff v. State Farm General Insurance Co. author | Civil Procedure | Jun. 10, 2020 | 
| Insalaco v. Hope Lutheran Church author | Torts | May 29, 2020 | 
| In re Shelton concurring | Criminal Law and Procedure | Apr. 17, 2020 | 
| People v. Matthews concurring | Criminal Law and Procedure | Apr. 16, 2020 | 
| City of Warren Police and Fire Retirement System v. Natera Inc. author | Securities | Mar. 25, 2020 | 
| Roth v. Jelley author | probate_and_trusts | Feb. 26, 2020 | 
| In re Amber K. author | Juveniles | Feb. 25, 2020 | 
| People v. Harper author | Criminal Law and Procedure | Jan. 13, 2020 | 
| Taniguchi v. Restoration Homes LLC author | Real Property | Dec. 18, 2019 | 
| Modification: Ashmus v. Superior Court (San Mateo) author | Civil Procedure | Dec. 17, 2019 | 
| Ashmus v. Superior Court (San Mateo) author | Civil Procedure | Dec. 6, 2019 | 
| California Taxpayers Action Network v. Taber Construction, Inc. author | Government | Dec. 3, 2019 | 
| People v. McCann author | Criminal Law and Procedure | Oct. 18, 2019 | 
| Christensen v. Lightbourne affirmed | Administrative Agencies | Jul. 9, 2019 | 
| People v. Reyes author | Criminal Law and Procedure | May 21, 2019 | 
| Modification: Taniguchi v. Restoration Homes author | Real Property | May 6, 2019 | 
| Taniguchi v. Restoration Homes author | Real Property | May 2, 2019 | 
| People v. Salinas-Jacobo author | Criminal Law and Procedure | Apr. 1, 2019 | 
| People v. Beman author | Criminal Law and Procedure | Feb. 25, 2019 | 
| Darrin v. Miller author | statutory_interpretation | Feb. 25, 2019 | 
| Modification: Bunzl Distribution v. Franchise Tax Bd. affirmed | Tax | Oct. 25, 2018 | 
| People v. Jones author | Criminal Law and Procedure | Oct. 19, 2018 | 
| Bunzl Distribution v. Franchise Tax Bd. affirmed | Tax | Oct. 2, 2018 | 
| Maplebear v. Busick author | Arbitration | Aug. 23, 2018 | 
| People v. Brown author | Criminal Law and Procedure | May 29, 2018 | 
| Small Property Owners, etc., v. City and County of San Francisco author | Government | Apr. 13, 2018 | 
| SMS Financial v. Cornerstone Tile Co. author | Torts | Jan. 30, 2018 | 
| Zuniga v. Workers' Compensation Appeals Board author | Workers' Compensation | Jan. 29, 2018 | 
| Davis v. Superior Court author | Criminal Law and Procedure | Jan. 3, 2018 | 
| City of Fontana et al. v. California Department of Tax and Fee Administration concurring | Administrative Agencies | Nov. 30, 2017 | 
| Placerville Historic Preservation League v. Judicial Council of California (County of El Dorado) author | Environmental Law | Oct. 17, 2017 | 
| Christensen v. Lightbourne author | Administrative Agencies | Oct. 10, 2017 | 
| Vallejo Police Officers Assoc. v. City of Vallejo author | Contracts | Sep. 25, 2017 | 
| Cross v. Facebook concurring | Anti-SLAPP | Aug. 11, 2017 | 
| Marriage of Kumar author | Family Law | Aug. 1, 2017 | 
| Duarte v. Pacific Specialty Insurance Co. author | Insurance | Jul. 3, 2017 | 
| Case Name | Topic | Role | Published | 
|---|---|---|---|
| 2121 Broadway Inc. v. Andrei Urazov, Home Impressions Inc., Eugene Shenkar | Contracts | judge | Aug. 6, 2005 | 
| Title | Court | Published | 
|---|---|---|
| The Appeal of Appeals | 1st District, Division 2 (San Francisco) | Jul. 13, 2021 | 
| Good and Ready | San Francisco County Superior Court | May 11, 2008 | 
| Case | Category | Published | 
|---|---|---|
| People v. Warner author | Criminal Law and Procedure | Oct. 22, 2025 | 
| People v. Krueger author | Criminal Law and Procedure | Oct. 22, 2025 | 
| People v. Dain author | Criminal Law and Procedure | Oct. 15, 2025 | 
| Solano County Orderly Growth Committee v. City of Fairfield author | Municipal Law | Aug. 29, 2025 | 
| International Currency Technologies v. ICT, Inc. author | Remedies | Jun. 30, 2025 | 
| Applegate v. Carrington Foreclosure Services, LLC author | Real Property | Jun. 27, 2025 | 
| Rose v. Hobby Lobby Stores author | Employment Law | May 15, 2025 | 
| Koi Nation of Northern California v. City of Clearlake author | Native American Affairs | Mar. 17, 2025 | 
| People v. Bravo author | Criminal Law and Procedure | Jan. 8, 2025 | 
| People v. Davis author | Criminal Law and Procedure | Dec. 19, 2024 | 
| People v. Royal author | Criminal Law and Procedure | Oct. 24, 2024 | 
| Bath v. State of California author | Government | Oct. 24, 2024 | 
| A.H. v. Tamalpais Union High School Dist. author | Education | Sep. 25, 2024 | 
| Nassiri v. City of Lafayette author | Environmental Law | Jul. 18, 2024 | 
| People v. Morales author | Criminal Law and Procedure | Jun. 21, 2024 | 
| Williams v. J-M Manufacturing Company author | Torts | May 23, 2024 | 
| Kime v. Dignity Health, Inc. author | Health Care | Apr. 26, 2024 | 
| People v. Dain author | Criminal Law and Procedure | Jan. 31, 2024 | 
| People v. Underwood author | Criminal Law and Procedure | Jan. 30, 2024 | 
| People v. Ponder author | Criminal Law and Procedure | Oct. 26, 2023 | 
| People v. Narro author | Criminal Law and Procedure | Sep. 8, 2023 | 
| Marriage of Hearn author | Family Law | Aug. 11, 2023 | 
| Doe v. CFR Enterprises, Inc. author | Torts | Jul. 28, 2023 | 
| In re Damari Y. author | Dependency | Jun. 19, 2023 | 
| McKneely v. Superior Court (People) author | Criminal Law and Procedure | May 26, 2023 | 
| Jack v. Ring LLC author | Arbitration | May 26, 2023 | 
| In re Jonathan C.M. author | Dependency | May 24, 2023 | 
| Gola v. University of San Francisco dissenting | Employment Law | Apr. 14, 2023 | 
| Ruegg & Ellsworth v. City of Berkeley author | Civil Procedure | Mar. 14, 2023 | 
| People v. Oliva author | Criminal Law and Procedure | Mar. 10, 2023 | 
| Gostev v. Skillz Platform author | Arbitration | Feb. 28, 2023 | 
| Degala v. John Stewart Company author | Torts | Feb. 8, 2023 | 
| People v. Ornelas author | Criminal Law and Procedure | Jan. 31, 2023 | 
| Sarah K. v. Superior Court (Sonoma County Human Services Department) author | Dependency | Jan. 17, 2023 | 
| Doe v. Massage Envy Franchising, LLC author | Arbitration | Dec. 29, 2022 | 
| Doe v. Finke author | Constitutional Law | Dec. 22, 2022 | 
| Modification: In re Foster author | Criminal Law and Procedure | Dec. 2, 2022 | 
| In re Foster author | Criminal Law and Procedure | Nov. 2, 2022 | 
| Sarkany v. West author | Civil Procedure | Aug. 31, 2022 | 
| People v. Caparaz author | Criminal Law and Procedure | Jul. 1, 2022 | 
| Turo v. Superior Court (People) author | Business Law | Jun. 29, 2022 | 
| People v. Padilla-Martel author | Constitutional Law | May 3, 2022 | 
| Wong v. Restoration Robotics author | Securities | May 2, 2022 | 
| Modification: Gajanan v. City and County of San Francisco author | Tax | Apr. 28, 2022 | 
| Gajanan v. City and County of San Francisco author | Tax | Apr. 26, 2022 | 
| People v. Pantoja author | Criminal Law and Procedure | Apr. 14, 2022 | 
| In re Cesar G. author | Juveniles | Feb. 14, 2022 | 
| Hutcheson v. Superior Court (UBS Financial Services) author | Employment Law | Feb. 9, 2022 | 
| People v. James author | Criminal Law and Procedure | Nov. 1, 2021 | 
| Doe v. The Regents of the University of California author | Administrative Agencies | Oct. 21, 2021 | 
| Doe v. The Regents of the University of California author | Administrative Agencies | Oct. 21, 2021 | 
| Pilliod v. Monsanto Co. author | Torts | Aug. 11, 2021 | 
| People v. Bankers Insurance Co. author | Criminal Law and Procedure | Jun. 11, 2021 | 
| People v. Clotfelter author | Criminal Law and Procedure | Jun. 4, 2021 | 
| People v. McInnis author | Criminal Law and Procedure | May 3, 2021 | 
| People v. McCloud author | Criminal Law and Procedure | Apr. 14, 2021 | 
| In re R.A. author | Dependency | Mar. 15, 2021 | 
| People v. Hall author | Criminal Law and Procedure | Nov. 27, 2020 | 
| Denny v. Arntz author | Government | Oct. 16, 2020 | 
| Carter v. Pulte Home Corporation concurring | Insurance | Jul. 24, 2020 | 
| Modification: Fadeeff v. State Farm General Insurance Co. author | Civil Procedure | Jul. 2, 2020 | 
| Eghtesad v. State Farm General Insurance Company author | Civil Procedure | Jul. 1, 2020 | 
| Fadeeff v. State Farm General Insurance Co. author | Civil Procedure | Jun. 10, 2020 | 
| Insalaco v. Hope Lutheran Church author | Torts | May 29, 2020 | 
| In re Shelton concurring | Criminal Law and Procedure | Apr. 17, 2020 | 
| People v. Matthews concurring | Criminal Law and Procedure | Apr. 16, 2020 | 
| City of Warren Police and Fire Retirement System v. Natera Inc. author | Securities | Mar. 25, 2020 | 
| Roth v. Jelley author | probate_and_trusts | Feb. 26, 2020 | 
| In re Amber K. author | Juveniles | Feb. 25, 2020 | 
| People v. Harper author | Criminal Law and Procedure | Jan. 13, 2020 | 
| Taniguchi v. Restoration Homes LLC author | Real Property | Dec. 18, 2019 | 
| Modification: Ashmus v. Superior Court (San Mateo) author | Civil Procedure | Dec. 17, 2019 | 
| Ashmus v. Superior Court (San Mateo) author | Civil Procedure | Dec. 6, 2019 | 
| California Taxpayers Action Network v. Taber Construction, Inc. author | Government | Dec. 3, 2019 | 
| People v. McCann author | Criminal Law and Procedure | Oct. 18, 2019 | 
| Christensen v. Lightbourne affirmed | Administrative Agencies | Jul. 9, 2019 | 
| People v. Reyes author | Criminal Law and Procedure | May 21, 2019 | 
| Modification: Taniguchi v. Restoration Homes author | Real Property | May 6, 2019 | 
| Taniguchi v. Restoration Homes author | Real Property | May 2, 2019 | 
| People v. Salinas-Jacobo author | Criminal Law and Procedure | Apr. 1, 2019 | 
| People v. Beman author | Criminal Law and Procedure | Feb. 25, 2019 | 
| Darrin v. Miller author | statutory_interpretation | Feb. 25, 2019 | 
| Modification: Bunzl Distribution v. Franchise Tax Bd. affirmed | Tax | Oct. 25, 2018 | 
| People v. Jones author | Criminal Law and Procedure | Oct. 19, 2018 | 
| Bunzl Distribution v. Franchise Tax Bd. affirmed | Tax | Oct. 2, 2018 | 
| Maplebear v. Busick author | Arbitration | Aug. 23, 2018 | 
| People v. Brown author | Criminal Law and Procedure | May 29, 2018 | 
| Small Property Owners, etc., v. City and County of San Francisco author | Government | Apr. 13, 2018 | 
| SMS Financial v. Cornerstone Tile Co. author | Torts | Jan. 30, 2018 | 
| Zuniga v. Workers' Compensation Appeals Board author | Workers' Compensation | Jan. 29, 2018 | 
| Davis v. Superior Court author | Criminal Law and Procedure | Jan. 3, 2018 | 
| City of Fontana et al. v. California Department of Tax and Fee Administration concurring | Administrative Agencies | Nov. 30, 2017 | 
| Placerville Historic Preservation League v. Judicial Council of California (County of El Dorado) author | Environmental Law | Oct. 17, 2017 | 
| Christensen v. Lightbourne author | Administrative Agencies | Oct. 10, 2017 | 
| Vallejo Police Officers Assoc. v. City of Vallejo author | Contracts | Sep. 25, 2017 | 
| Cross v. Facebook concurring | Anti-SLAPP | Aug. 11, 2017 | 
| Marriage of Kumar author | Family Law | Aug. 1, 2017 | 
| Duarte v. Pacific Specialty Insurance Co. author | Insurance | Jul. 3, 2017 | 
| Case Name | Topic | Role | Published | 
|---|---|---|---|
| 2121 Broadway Inc. v. Andrei Urazov, Home Impressions Inc., Eugene Shenkar | Contracts | judge | Aug. 6, 2005 | 
 

 
